Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Theresa Albert

GET UPDATES FROM Theresa Albert
 

The Truth About Breakfast Sandwiches

Posted: 11/01/2012 12:55 pm

Come on sunshine, what can you show me?!

You know you want to turn that steering wheel into the line up at the drive through. A quickie breakfast sandwich ought to wake you up, right? A new study says that this is the route to artery disaster, its all over the news. But let take a closer look...

How did they conduct this study?

They took healthy non-smoking university students and tested their VTI (VTI is the velocity time interval -- the speed that blood moves through an artery which is an indicator of how healthy the artery is) before and after a 900 calorie breakfast sandwich containing 50 grams of fat.

Nobody eats this much without knowing they are doing damage. It just isn't a reasonable way to eat whether you are at home or in your car.

What did the study show?Within a couple of hours the VTI was reduced by 15 per cent which is likely a temporary problem. It is true that if you do this over and over for a lifetime, vessels will eventually become less able to move blood effectively. So don't eat that much and don't do it often.

So, why were breakfast sandwiches highlighted?

There is nothing in those breakfast sandwiches that is any worse than anything you would make at home! It is strictly a sexy way to tell a story but the truth is that there are better and worse choices no matter where you are eating. Though 900 calories and 50 grams of fat is an exorbitant amount of food.

Interestingly, they only compared this crazy breakfast to "no breakfast" not a "better breakfast." Let's hope this is the next study. It would be interesting to see what happened when the reasonable egg sandwich without the cheese and sausage would have done.

So what do we do? Never eat breakfast sandwiches?

Even the Heart and Stroke Foundation agrees that it is an unreasonable solution to never eat away from home. We know that some kind of breakfast is crucial and if you can't find the time or brain space to make it at home, most places offer healthier options. Low sugar oatmeal? Yogurt and fruit? Small egg sandwich, no cheese, no sausage?

No matter where you eat, or for which meal, you want a lean, breakfast full of nutrients, protein and fibre, and not the calorie/fat bomb that two big fatty sandwiches may offer.

So the take home message is "be reasonable, choose the lighter option." Oh dear, sexy story over.

My Comments on CTV News...

Loading Slideshow...
  • Eggs In A Cup

    Two-minute scrambled eggs in a cup: Spray a mug with non-stick spray. Pour in 2 beaten eggs mixed with 30 ml (2 tbsp) milk. Cover with plastic wrap, leaving small gap for steam. Microwave on medium-high for 1 minute and 30 seconds to 1 minute and 45 seconds, stirring several times during cooking. Cover and let stand for 30 seconds to 1 minute. Serve with whole-grain toast and a pear or any fruit on hand.

  • Smoothie

    Fruity smoothie in a vacuum flask; bagel with almond butter and apple slices.

  • Lunch For Breakfast

    Tuna salad made with sliced red grapes and chopped lettuce stuffed into 1/2 a whole-wheat pita plus yogurt.

  • Prepare Ahead

    Hard-boiled egg (they keep for a week in the refrigerator with the shell on), yogurt drink, fruit cup and bread sticks.

  • Make-Your-Own Yogurt Parfaits:

    Use any fancy dessert cups. Toppings can include pecans, walnuts, dried cranberries, cherries or chopped apricots, raisins, vanilla, cinnamon, any chopped fresh, unsweetened frozen or canned fruit, dry whole-grain or high-fibre cereal, granola, coconut. Organize toppings the night before.

  • Go English

    Canned baked beans served over toast with orange wedges.

  • Leftovers

    Reheat and add a glass of milk and piece of fruit.

  • F Is For Freeze

    Defrost in the microwave or pop into the toaster. Heat frozen berries in the microwave with a little maple syrup for a fruity topping.

  • Soup

    Add any leftover cooked meat, tofu or chicken, brown rice or a handful of frozen vegetables. Serve with whole-grain crackers and seasonal fruit.

  • CLT Sandwich

    Cheese, lettuce and tomato layered on a whole-wheat English muffin plus grapes and yogurt.

 

Follow Theresa Albert on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@theresaalbert

FOLLOW CANADA LIVING
Come on sunshine, what can you show me?! You know you want to turn that steering wheel into the line up at the drive through. A quickie breakfast sandwich ought to wake you up, right? A new study say...
Come on sunshine, what can you show me?! You know you want to turn that steering wheel into the line up at the drive through. A quickie breakfast sandwich ought to wake you up, right? A new study say...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:29 PM on 11/01/2012
This study was totally useless. And is why I am becoming more and more exasperated with such biased studies.

A proper study would have compared the reaction to a variety of foods in the same situation.

What happens if you eat a bowl of oatmeal, or granola.

Devise the theoretically perfect breakfast, and test the reaction to that.

Breakfast gets it's name from breaking the overnight fast. I have a feeling that there is a signifigant change in various bodily functions as your body digests the first food after twelve hours or so without.

This study might have had a lot less impact if they'd instead said that there was a five percent difference in how your body reacts to a healthy breakfast as compared to the breakfast sandwich.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
04:14 PM on 11/01/2012
Honestly I wonder how our species made it this far when anything and everything is bad for us.
03:11 PM on 11/01/2012
Where are they finding these 900 calorie breakfast sandwiches? According to the Tim Horton's Nutritional calculator, a cheese bagel BELT with egg, bacon and cheese is 420 cal/16g fat. The breakfast sandwich with a biscuit, egg, bacon and cheese is 430 cal/24g fat. Maybe they're having sammies at McD's, but their calculator says the bacon and egg bagel is 620 calories/28g fat.

While neither is going to make you skinny, screaming that "breakfast sandwiches are 900 cal/50g fat" seems to be nothing but hyperbole.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joseph Wallac
06:55 PM on 11/01/2012
McD's has some of the "better" options with a standard egg Mcmuffin coming in aorund 300 calories with a decent amount of protein. and you can cut the calories a bit by removing cheese and Canadian bacon
photo
Wheelo
A man a plan a canal Panama
01:56 PM on 11/01/2012
Aw shucks, I was hoping for something more along the lines of: EGG MCMUFFINS ARE MADE OF PEOPLE!

Actually I tend to worry more about the canned food-service grade griddle lubricant they use to cook these breakfast sammiches on. Having cooked in restaurants and read the labels, that stuff is a frightening stew of chemicals designed to taste like something real.
01:35 PM on 11/01/2012
Maybe skip the hash brown and the ketchup.