Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tim Knight

GET UPDATES FROM Tim Knight
 

Watching the Watchdog: This Aboriginal Revolt is For Real

Posted: 12/21/2012 1:59 pm

Tim Knight writes the regular media column, Watching the Watchdog, for HuffPost Canada.


In the middle of the Ottawa River there is an island called Victoria, named by the white settlers to honour their queen across the water.

On Victoria Island is a tepee. And in the tepee on this freezing cold first day of winter sits Theresa Spence who is Chief of the Attawapiskat First Nation and holds an eagle feather in her hand.

For nearly two weeks now she's been on a hunger strike to try to force Canada's government to rescue the peoples of our First Nations.

"I am willing to die for my people," she says "because the pain is too much and it's time for the government to realize what it's doing to us."

Ironically, from the chief's tepee on Victoria Island, which is Algonquin territory, you can see the splendid Canadian Parliament where our laws are made, and the Supreme Court of Canada, where our laws are enforced.

Chief Spence is not alone in her anger. Across the country, First Nations people are meeting and planning resistance and already some are closing highways. And from coast to coast, the movement Idle No More grows to protest against generations of traditional Canadian government indifference toward endemic First Nations poverty, desperation and despair.

How has it come to this?

Simple. It's what inevitably happens eventually when colonial powers invade aboriginal land.

The newcomers carry big guns and speak grand words about the glory of their civilization and the power of their mighty god. And they justify the invasion by trying to destroy native culture, "civilize" the people and turn them into lesser versions of the colonizers.

In recent history it's almost always been paler people doing this to darker people.

It's called racism.

But what, you ask, has this to do with Canada? Our two colonial invaders, France and Great Britain, certainly didn't behave as badly toward the indigenous people as some other colonial powers.

Colonialists "behaving badly" though, is just a matter of degree. And no colonial power is ever ready to admit -- and voluntarily right -- its wrongs.

For instance, during Algeria's eight year war of liberation from France, perhaps 1-millon people were killed. But it took until last week before France admitted that its colonization of Algeria included both torture and massacres.

That's when new French president Francois Hollande told the Algerian parliament: "For 132 years, Algeria was subjected to a brutal and unfair system -- colonization. I acknowledge the suffering it caused."

As for the British, for years Kenyans have accused them of covering up systemic atrocities during the Mau Mau rebellion against colonialism back in the fifties.

Now, a British High Court has ruled that the government can be sued for those atrocities.

Gitu wa Kahengeri, of the Mau Mau War Veterans Association, says they're asking for reparations and a formal apology from the British. "We are looking for compensation for all of the people whose lives they have destroyed."

"We are also looking for them to come out and apologize to the people of Kenya and, of course, to the people of the world because what they did here is completely inhuman."

It's believed some 20,000 Mau Mau fighters were killed by the British during the rebellion, thousands were tortured and more than 1,000 arbitrarily executed.

Guardian Journalist David Anderson writes: "At no other time or place in the British empire was capital punishment dispensed so liberally -- the total is more than double the number executed by the French in Algeria."

Claims of abuse -- and coverup of abuse -- under British colonial rule have been made in other former British colonies all the way from Cyprus to Guyana.

Anderson writes that it's time for Britain to examine its colonial past: "Squaring up to the seamier side of our empire is long overdue. However benevolent empires aim to be, they are invariably built on political, economic and military domination. Empires are by their very nature exploitative."

Now, Canada can't be accused of such heinous colonial crimes as the French admit to committing in Algeria and the British likely committed in Kenya. Then again, armed revolts against colonial rule here have been small and sporadic.

But Canada can rightly and accurately be accused of one of the most elemental sins of colonialism -- trying to destroy aboriginal culture and assimilate aboriginal people, then abandoning them when they refuse to become ersatz whites.

Which brings us all the way back to Chief Theresa Spence of the Attawapiskat First Nation people who sits fasting in the tepee on Victoria Island, which is Algonquin territory, holding the eagle feather and looking out at Canada's Parliament and Supreme Court.

And the Idle No More protest movement.

And a forecast -- that this time the anger of our first peoples won't be placated with an apology in parliament or more easy, unfulfilled promises of reform sometime in the future.

This time, I believe, the revolt is for real.

We ignore it at our peril.

Loading Slideshow...

 

Follow Tim Knight on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TimKnight6

FOLLOW CANADA
Tim Knight writes the regular media column, Watching the Watchdog, for HuffPost Canada. In the middle of the Ottawa River there is an island called Victoria, named by the white settlers to honour th...
Tim Knight writes the regular media column, Watching the Watchdog, for HuffPost Canada. In the middle of the Ottawa River there is an island called Victoria, named by the white settlers to honour th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 23
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:18 AM on 12/24/2012
Historically, the oppressor has always denigrated those he oppressed. The most glaring example is of course the Holocaust when the Nazis justified their inhumane treatment of Jews because, they insisted, Jews were nothing more than "vermin." The Brits preached that the people in every part of the world where they ruled (parts of Africa, India, etc) needed guidance and a strict hand as though those people were little more than children. In Canada, the whites did everything they could to stamp out the lesser brown culture, even removing children from their parents. And now, some of us are annoyed that those damned Indians won't shut up and assimilate.
04:02 AM on 12/24/2012
"Idle No More grows to protest against generations of traditional Canadian government indifference toward endemic First Nations poverty, desperation and despair."
Misleading. Bill C45 spurred this revolt. Destroying all Canadian's water and civil protections is a threat to everyone. This is why Idle No More is a Global movement. I hope them all the best. It may be our last chance at saving our country.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:38 PM on 12/23/2012
Tim Knight, you're wrong. Do you think Haper cut funding to first nations, health care, environment, post secondary education, and the military for kicks? We are trapped in a global race to the bottom. http://ctj.org/ctjreports/2011/06/twelve_corporations_pay_effective_tax_rate_of_negative_15_on_171_billion_in_profits_reap_624_billion.php http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/25/business/economy/25tax.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hal Wood
03:39 PM on 12/23/2012
Natives are being dragged down by themselves. This constant pressure on their young to absorb a culture that has never been described. They must feel trapped by not being Indian enough and forced by chiefs and band councils to not progress to function anywhere else.The Chiefs are depressing their own people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kapjam
12:58 AM on 12/24/2012
The dominant culture for most young aboriginals is a copy of unemployed and angry lack youth in the US. Just watch the various faux music awards as they imitate the vey lowest standard in US arts.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:33 PM on 12/23/2012
Judging by the very low turn outs for todays protests the "revolt" has already fizzled. Just a handful in Vancouver. Not even a mention of the "revolt" on HP Canada page.
05:17 AM on 12/22/2012
Ah, and the usual bilious comments of the white majority ensue. Did your mom go to a residential school? Was your dad taught that his language and culture were an offence to God? Was your uncle relieved of his sexual innocence as a child by a community leader? When your sister went missing in Vancouver's Downtown East-side, did the police fail to investigate? Were your brothers and sisters separated from their parents and each other and sent to foster care?
Yeah, native Canadians get some tax breaks. Yeah, a few of your tax dollars go to supporting some 'other' people. People who have been systematically held outside our nation's economic system. People who have a hard time getting even low-paying service industry jobs due to racism. People whose families were treated like chattel by the federal government for generations. Native Canadians aren't crying out for handouts, they're crying out for healing and true equality. It's the British North America Act and the Indian Act that gave aboriginal Canadians their political power in terms of their traditional lands.
I too, am a first generation Canadian, my folks immigrated following the second world war, and indeed, some others were run out of Germany earlier in the century. And yes, some of them faced discrimination whilst assimilating in their new society. But they were white. And that made their experiences in our country different. To pretend otherwise is to ignore history.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Tim Knight
10:41 AM on 12/22/2012
Canada’s original people — the people of Turtle Island — somehow survived the official governmental “kill the Indian in the child” policy and years of futile land claims, official neglect and broken promises.

Does anyone really doubt that the government would have moved generously and swiftly it were white settlers and their descendants who endured such treatment and now have to live with its results?

Does anyone really doubt that a civilized nation would long since have vastly improved the pathetic indigenous people’s education system and cleaned up its rural slums?

Does anyone really doubt that Canada’s First Nations are in the right now they say enough, no more patience, no more promises, and demand immediate action to save their people?

Anyone?
10:12 AM on 12/23/2012
And exactly what is this immediate action required to save their people? What are they asking for?

My grandparents were killed in the holocaust, my mother and father miraculously survived. After they were liberated they were homeless, penniless and refugees for nealy 2 years before they were allowed to immigrate to Canada. No resititution or reparations were ever offered or payed by any country. Simply and matter of fact, they had to live with these results and move forward or wither and die. Patience, promises and demands were not an option.

My parents were raised with the attitude that you need to work hard, go to school, get a job have self respect and personal accountabilty. This culture of accountabilty and hardwork has been passed on to me and now to my children and is a recipe for success. Waiting for someone to feel sorry for you and give you something you think you are entitled is an exercise in futility.
12:59 AM on 12/22/2012
My grandparents became displaced people in 1919 Europe - their unique culture destroyed. But they move on and build new lives as all people must do. The Native people of Canada have had struggles for sure, but we are all people of the one earth and we must get along with the reality and not continually fight old battles. This article I find extremely patronizing and offers not one solution - just a reheated history lesson of select (selected by the writer) examples. I wish our Native peoples well, I mean that, but we have spent billions on their development and culture and yet are accused of destroying it at the same time because it is 2012 now (not 1795) and progress happens. We need to move forward and with more power to the Native peoples comes responsibility - an issue us non Native folk are often too sensitive to bring up - but which is so obviously lacking
11:45 PM on 12/21/2012
I am so tired of the whining and complaining of Indians; their sense of entitlement is astounding. This is not their country, never has been. They can get a job, get a good education, drive 2 cars and live in a nice neighbourhood - - if they want. The noble saveage is dead and buried and all the drum beating is of no value. Do what we all must do with past pain and injustice, put it behind you and look forward in a positive way. Teach your children values, not how to protest and suck on the public teat.
01:08 AM on 12/22/2012
You're kidding, right?
01:52 AM on 12/22/2012
pardon my french: but where the hell did you come from?
11:28 PM on 12/21/2012
Ok, where to start...The facts are that the land which is now known as Canada was once inhabited by many native tribes which often engaged in inter-tribal warfare. They often took slaves, raped their opponents' women and drove others off the hunting grounds which the stronger tribe desired. Brutal? Yes, just like the rest of the human race. Then these stone-age people then came into contact with the technologically superior Europeans. Unlike the movie "Avatar", when primitive people run into those who are more advanced, they lose. Lucky for Canada's natives, the French and English treated them pretty well - considering the standards of the day. Fast forward a few hundred years. Canadians ask, "OK, what do natives want?" The short answer is: everything. Natives want to live in a modern, developed country with access to advanced health care and education. They want full control over law, language, all natural resources, and local government. They want final say over (and a cut of) any development project that is in the national interest. They don't want to pay taxes. They want other citizens to fork over billions to them - forever. Natives holding a perpetual grudge against the rest of their countrymen makes about as much sense as the Brits being choked at the Italians because their lands were once conquered by the Romans. I believe there will come a day when the majority will finally say, "Enough already. Sort yourselves out." Most Canadians are willing to assist, but that status
05:24 AM on 12/22/2012
Yeah, it's as nuts as the Irish being p-o'd about the Brits conquering them (and not leaving), or the Palestinians being p-o'd at Israelis for taking over their land (and not leaving), or any other once-proud nation thats lost all its power to outsiders. Seriously, where do those darned aboriginals get off?
Oh yeah, and the majority of Canadians kissed off aboriginal Canadians generations ago. That's pretty much where your general attitude to your fellow countryfolk arises from. I bet your dad told that same rant back in the seventies...
This comment has been removed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kapjam
01:02 AM on 12/24/2012
Perfect summary of where we are today. FN leadership has developed an attitude in their people where instead of working together to move forwards they chose to wait for a fictitious loto payout.
09:20 PM on 12/21/2012
White guilt baloney. Theresa spence makes $70,000 a year for doing practically nothing in the middle of nowhere. That's plenty.