Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tim Knight

GET UPDATES FROM Tim Knight
 

Watching the Watchdog: Sun TV's Right vs. Left Jabs on Brazeau/Trudeau Fight

Posted: 04/ 3/2012 12:19 pm

Veteran newsman Tim Knight contributes a regular blog to HuffPost, analyzing and rating broadcast and Internet journalism programs.

As journalism goes, so goes democracy -- Sun TV's coverage of Saturday night's Liberal/Conservative fight was a triumph of reality T.V.

Ezra Levant and Brian Lilley, two of Sun's most opinionated poobahs, play boxing commentators for the fight. They clearly know little about boxing. But that doesn't matter. Because they aren't there, all dressed up in their tuxes, to fulminate about jabs vs. hooks. They certainly aren't there to practice journalism. They're actually there, for lo, those many, many hours, to commit reality TV.

On and on they fulminate, mostly in pre-taped edited segments, long before the bell rings for the first fisticuffs to fly. They find more ways to criticize the recent budget for being too liberal and diss that lefty CBC all over again.

They have a hero -- Senator Patrick Brazeau, who just happens to be a Conservative.

They have a villain -- Justin Trudeau, an MP who just happens to be a Liberal.

Levant, forecasting a walkover for the much-muscled Brazeau: "This is a one-round fight!"

Levant, mocking Trudeau: "Use your ballet training ... we don't want those lips to be bleeding."

All this before the actual fight, which turns out to be the only genuine part of the Sun T.V. coverage because the fight, unlike the coverage, is honest.

2012-04-03-sunlogo.jpg And all the while, sitting on the bottom left of my screen is Sun's big, red-and-white logo.

This is news, it claims.

At first, I ignore it. All stations plaster their logos on the screen. Then I go to the Sun News Network to check some facts and discover that same red-and-white Sun News logo on the lower left of the screen for every one of its programs.

But apart from some perfunctory, conventional stuff in the daytime, Sun T.V. doesn't do news.

Instead, it does reality TV and the scripted plot is -- only far right-wing politics can save Canada and yes, the world.

It's reality T.V., like Survivor and Jersey Shore.

Just in case you're a 12-year-old kid who thinks, for instance, that Survivor and Jersey Shore are real, you should know that reality T.V. isn't real. It does fakery, not reality (noun: "the state of things as they actually exist").

The characters in reality T.V. are carefully chosen to fit pre-determined stereotypes and play pre-determined roles. They have scripts. Heroes vs. villains, that sort of thing. Snooki's given her role, slips into character, and tries to be even more revolting than she was last week.

Traditional news offers at least two sides to any controversy. Sun offers only one. The hard, far right. Conspiracies are everywhere. And only Sun realizes it. Only Sun does honest journalism. Only Sun can save the world.

Sun TV is to honest news reporting as the WWE's Wrestlemania TV show is to Olympic wrestling. Or military justice is to justice.

A quick check on recent Sun's programs comes up with:

Charles Adler starts an interview: " ...this namby-pamby Earth Hour crapola." News? Journalism?

Michael Coren on Thomas Mulcair, new leader of the NDP: "Never trust a man with a beard like that. Those glisteny eyes. Don't trust him." And, inevitably: "Why does the CBC hate the poor?" News? Journalism?

Brian Lilley on a court decision on prostitution: "The Ontario Court of Appeal has agreed with a lower court ruling put out by a judge that doesn't deserve to sit on the bench." News? Journalism?
Verdict -- Sun TV is a conscious conspiracy to destroy traditional ethical journalism in our democracy and replace it with reality TV based entirely on far right-wing fantasy.

There, I've said it.

 

Follow Tim Knight on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TimKnight6

FOLLOW CANADA
Veteran newsman Tim Knight contributes a regular blog to HuffPost, analyzing and rating broadcast and Internet journalism programs. As journalism goes, so goes democracy -- Sun TV's coverage of Satu...
Veteran newsman Tim Knight contributes a regular blog to HuffPost, analyzing and rating broadcast and Internet journalism programs. As journalism goes, so goes democracy -- Sun TV's coverage of Satu...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
Peter Biesterfeld
Documentary film maker, writer, educator
04:11 PM on 04/04/2012
Journalism? Indeed. NOT. Have been sparring with the state broadcaster's Brian Lilley et al on Facebook about the Sun's press-release journalism and their tiresome anti-CBC fetish. Yes, we can change the channel but Knight's mission is a worthy one: to watch, analyze and throw critical light into ALL corners where the fourth estate claims to be serving up "Hard News and Straight Talk." I don't know if the Sun News Network is "A Farce To Be Reckoned With" as the Ryerson Review of Journalism would have us believe (http://rrj.ca/m18434/) that would be too kind. But media watchers' antennae go up, as they should, when silly reporter impersonators resort to stunt journalism for eyeballs spouting official PMO lore and trashing other thinkers. Keep swiveling that search light Tim Knight. Shine it everywhere, where and whenever the "show" gets in the way of the news and storytelling.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
canadagirl76
A mind is like a parachute, they work best open.
01:45 PM on 04/04/2012
I could not have said it better myself, Mr Knight! Thanks for your insight.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WeeTadBit
08:45 AM on 04/04/2012
You've said it Tim, and thank you for doing so, and keep spreading the word. We watch the appalling mess called Fox News and shake our heads in disgust, and yet we have a conservative government that will use Sun News as a propaganda tool. The result of letting these right wing nutters use this platform to spread their so-called "truth," will not be very beneficial for the health of our democracy.
01:04 AM on 04/04/2012
"Sun TV is a conscious conspiracy to destroy traditional ethical journalism in our democracy and replace it with reality TV based entirely on far right-wing fantasy." Good summary. And 'fantasy' is a good word for the way conservative' minds now operate. Conservatives didn't always hate their own minds or prefer the fantasy of ideology. I am old enough to remember when most 'conservatives' were not only reasonable and rational, but had ethical INTEGRITY. Those were the days! With the takeover of the 'conservative' label by the far-right, ethical integrity, along with mental integrity. was flushed down an ideological toilet.
05:40 PM on 04/06/2012
Well said Jim. I, too, miss the days when there was more ethics and integrity in everyone's behaviour.
06:45 PM on 04/03/2012
Sun TV does not have all that many viewers, so why the worry? Don't you trust Canadians to inform themselves with diverse opinion? All TV news is entertainment and comes from an ideological perspective. Some just pretend to hide their objectivity better.
06:20 PM on 04/03/2012
Sun TVs' "storytelling", something evidently only appreciated by Mr. Knight when it's a story he likes, is not being delivered to the screen via a $34 annual tax levied on every single breathing Canadian. If people don't like it, they switch the channel or turn the T.V. off - and the market will fix Sun TV.

Not something you can say about the CBC or Radio-Canada. A network which not only reaches into our pockets, but broadcasts abusive speech. Lest we not forget its shameful treatment of the election of Barack Obama on Radio-Canada's end of year flagship "Bye Bye" 2008 broadcast: "It will be good to have a Negro in the White House. It will be practical. Black on white, it will be easier to shoot him." Or reaching for the crotch of the actor playing Obama to confirm whether black men have a "big bizoune".

http://www.crtc.gc.ca/eng/publications/reports/cbsc.pdf

Brought to you by CBC / Radio-Canada. Mr. Knight's former employer, incidentally.
03:58 PM on 04/03/2012
Sun News is like all of the other channels, they have their ideology and they stick to it. After watching all of the major news channels, I think that Al Jazeera (English) has the some of the most balanced coverage. There is shrieking and gnashing of teeth on all "news" channels and to a moderate, MSNBC's Maddow is as bad as Fox's Beck for making me think that perhaps there is more opinion here than facts. The internet allows us to read a broad enough spectrum of viewpoints on each issue, that we are all better off than before.
If you never listen to the criticisms of your opponent, how are you going to to know how to convince them of your position and how will you find out if perhaps you are wrong?
03:56 PM on 04/03/2012
Perhaps the overwhelming majority of Canadians know that Sun News is a joke but to dismiss it is far to simplistic. By making 'news' of their right wing opinions far too absurd for the sane to swallow they are still shifting the discourse their way: Reformers don't even seem so crazy from this perspective. And, there is no reverse strategy for progressives to counterbalance this dumbing up of national poilitcal discourse because thinking is actually hard work that promotes diversity and cannot possible lead to a unified front of simnplicity.

Theirs is a strategy both well thought out and well funded and currently winning.
03:15 PM on 04/03/2012
I think the overwhelming majority of Canadians know that sun news is a joke. Even I occasionally watch it for the entertainment value (and I am a member of one of their most hated groups).

Most people on twitter were even saying that their extreme rhetoric makes moderate conservatives look bad or that they use their moment of fame to spew their toxic propaganda.

Overall people are kinda hoping Quebecor gets the message and invests their money in more profitable ventures.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DirkNeptune
I love raspberry pie, damn it.
01:21 PM on 04/03/2012
Having never watched SUN TV before, I was shocked at how one-sidedly non-stop they were at preaching their hard right ideology. The fact that it was a charity event did not slow them down one bit. They were determined to not let their temporary bump in viewership go to waste.

They are just as bad as FOX News which is, of course, what Harper wants. It's sad reflection of what Harper and his ilk have done to this once great country.
01:19 PM on 04/03/2012
Tim, whether or not your readers agree with you, your sure get us off our comfortable perches!

Thanks for another great blog.

I have a bone to pick with you, though: 12-year olds know when its reality TV.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Tim Knight
10:50 AM on 04/04/2012
I suspect 12-yar-olds know Sun News is reality TV in the same way they know their parents put boundaries around their freedoms in order to make them really, really unhappy.
georgee2
My Canada Includes Everyone
01:11 PM on 04/03/2012
I like Sun TV because you have nearly all the really bad commentators on 1 channel. Now I can skip right past and go to CBC & CNN to watch real news.