Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tim Knight

GET UPDATES FROM Tim Knight
 

Watching the Watchdog: The Great Firewall of Journalism

Posted: 11/23/2012 5:12 pm

Tim Knight writes the regular media column Watching the Watchdog, for HuffPost Canada.

I've got two new heroes. Their names are Cindy Michaels and Tony Consiglio. Until last Tuesday they were the top journalists and news anchors at a small TV station in Bangor, Maine across the border from Québec.

Then they quit. On air. Using their last minutes as anchors of the six o'clock news to say polite goodbyes.

The closest either came to explanation on air was: "some recent developments have come to our attention ... and departing together is the best alternative we can take."

Michaels, who was the station's news director, later offered some detail. "We both felt there was a lack of knowledge from ownership and upper management in running a newsroom, to the extent that I was not allowed to structure and direct them professionally. I couldn't do everything I wanted to as a news director. There was a regular undoing of decisions."


She added: "We were expected to do somewhat unbalanced news, politically, in general."

Consiglio, who was the station's executive producer, said: "I just wanted to know that I ... was being honest and ethical as a journalist, and I thought there were times when I wasn't able to do that."

So why are a couple of on-air anchor resignations in a nowhere city in another country enough for me or anyone else to add their names to the pantheon of journalistic heroes? It's because of the firewall these two respected -- and paid for with their jobs. That's the firewall between journalists (reporters, writers, anchors, producers, news directors etc.) and management.

The two groups are not of the same ilk, the same tribe. They live in different worlds. They have entirely different priorities. Managers exist to run the corporate side of things and make as much profit as possible for owners. (Public broadcasters like CBC do the same, with career advancement replacing profit motive.)

In the starkest of contrasts, journalists exist to seek the truth and report it as a public service, without fear or favour. The firewall between them is vital in that it protects the gathering and distribution of news from the commercial avarice and/or financial or political influence of managers and owners.

It protects the free marketplace of ideas. It guards journalism as a vital cornerstone of democracy. The firewall is there to keep your journalism honest. Every journalist with any time in the trenches has likely come across some form of managerial pressure to kill a story or angle it one way or another.

For instance, I spent a few months as training producer with then Toronto-based The Real News. Over those months, it became increasingly clear that only those stories syncing exactly with the world view of its boss, Paul Jay, and his financial backers would ever make the daily news feed.

In response, the small newsroom staff wrote a manifesto aimed at starting a union. Main objective was the obvious need for a written firewall between management and journalists:

"To ensure the traditional and vital separation of journalistic church and state, the offices of Chief Executive Officer (CEO) and Senior Editor [should] be separated."

TRN never did get a union. And I was fired.

One other personal example. In the late seventies, I was head of CBC TV news in Ottawa when we did an entirely innocuous story about contraception available at some local clinic. Right after it screened, station manager Paul Gaffney berated me for what he called its pro-contraception bias.

I showed him a video tape of the story. He claimed I'd had it doctored to remove the bias. I showed him the station tape which records everything broadcast. He insinuated that it too had been altered to remove the bias. Shortly thereafter, I was fired. These things happen.

Moral of the story is that without the firewall, Gaffney, the manager, would have seen the contraception story before it aired, and likely killed it. My favourite example of the sheer beauty and power of the firewall came up fairly recently at the New York Times.

The great, grey lady had just announced the appointment of a new Chief Executive Officer. His name was Mark Thompson, until then boss of the mighty BBC in Great Britain. Shortly thereafter, the BBC found itself deep in accusations that it had deliberately cancelled a newsroom investigation into Jimmy Savile, one of its biggest stars, accused of serial child sex abuse.

Enter the Times' ombudsman (public editor) Margaret Sullivan. She publicly questioned the appointment of her new boss, asking the classic question: "How likely is it that [Thompson] knew nothing?" She didn't stop there: "His integrity and decision-making are bound to affect the Times and its journalism -- profoundly. It's worth considering now whether he is the right person for the job, given this turn of events."

Such courage! Such integrity! Such respect for the firewall between journalism and management! And last I checked, she still works for the Times.

Point of all this, I suppose, is that sometimes the firewall between journalism and management -- church and state -- isn't enough to protect honest journalism. But much more often, it is. And without that firewall, there would be no honest journalism at all. And journalists like Cindy Michaels and Tony Consiglio and Margaret Sullivan would just do what they're damn well told.

And democracy would be the loser.

Loading Slideshow...
  • George Entwistle resignation

    BBC director general George Entwistle stands outside BBC Broadcasting House, London, after he announced his resignation over the "unacceptable" Newsnight broadcast which wrongly implicated a senior former Conservative in a child abuse scandal.

  • BBC crisis

    File photo dated 05/10/2010 of Culture Secretary Maria Miller, who today said the £450,000 severance pay for outgoing BBC director-general George Entwistle is "tough to justify considering the circumstances of Mr Entwistle's departure and his contractual arrangements".

  • BBC crisis

    Acting director general of the BBC Tim Davie arrives at New Broadcasting house in central London.

  • BBC crisis

    Acting director general of the BBC Tim Davie arrives at New Broadcasting house in central London.

  • BRITAIN-MEDIA-BBC-CHILD-SEX-POLITICS

    BBC employees arrive for work at the organisation's New Broadcasting House in central London, on November 12, 2012. The BBC's director of news, Helen Boaden, and her deputy, Stephen Mitchell, have stepped aside amid the crisis over late television star Jimmy Savile and a report wrongly accusing a politician of child abuse, the BBC said Monday. The announcement follows the resignation on Saturday of BBC director-general George Entwistle over another Newsnight report last week that wrongly implicated a senior political figure in abuse at a Welsh children's home in the 1970s. AFP PHOTO / WILL OLIVER (Photo credit should read WILL OLIVER/AFP/Getty Images)

  • BRITAIN-MEDIA-BBC-CHILD-SEX-POLITICS

    The BBC's offices at New Broadcasting House are pictured in central London, on November 12, 2012. The BBC's director of news, Helen Boaden, and her deputy, Stephen Mitchell, have stepped aside amid the crisis over late television star Jimmy Savile and a report wrongly accusing a politician of child abuse, the BBC said Monday. The announcement follows the resignation on Saturday of BBC director-general George Entwistle over another Newsnight report last week that wrongly implicated a senior political figure in abuse at a Welsh children's home in the 1970s. AFP PHOTO / WILL OLIVER (Photo credit should read WILL OLIVER/AFP/Getty Images)

  • BRITAIN-MEDIA-BBC-CHILD-SEX-POLITICS

    CROPPED VERSION The shadow of chairman of the BBC Trust Lord Chris Patten is reflected on a wall outside the BBC's offices in central London on November 11, 2012. Patten called for a radical overhaul of the world's largest broadcaster after it was plunged into crisis following the resignation of the director-general amid a sex abuse scandal. AFP PHOTO / JUSTIN TALLIS (Photo credit should read JUSTIN TALLIS/AFP/Getty Images)

  • George Entwistle resignation

    BBC director general George Entwistle (left) looks on as Chairman of the BBC Trust Lord Patten speaks to the media outside BBC Broadcasting House, London, after Mr Entwistle announced his resignation over the "unacceptable" Newsnight broadcast which wrongly implicated a senior former Conservative in a child abuse scandal.

  • George Entwistle resignation

    BBC director general George Entwistle (left) looks on as Chairman of the BBC Trust Lord Patten speaks to the media outside BBC Broadcasting House, London, after Mr Entwistle announced his resignation over the "unacceptable" Newsnight broadcast which wrongly implicated a senior former Conservative in a child abuse scandal.

  • George Entwistle resignation

    BBC director general George Entwistle speaks to the media outside BBC Broadcasting House, London, as he announced his resignation over the "unacceptable" Newsnight broadcast which wrongly implicated a senior former Conservative in a child abuse scandal.

  • Savile sex abuse investigation

    File photo dated 23/10/2012 of BBC Television Centre, Wood Lane, London, as the BBC revealed it is investigating nine allegations of "sexual harassment, assault or inappropriate conduct" among current staff and contributors as the fallout from the Jimmy Savile scandal continues.

  • Savile sex abuse investigation

    File photo dated 03/02/1999 of Sir Jimmy Savile, as the BBC revealed it is investigating nine allegations of "sexual harassment, assault or inappropriate conduct" among current staff and contributors as the fallout from the Jimmy Savile scandal continues.

  • Savile sex abuse investigation

    File photo dated 25/01/12 of Chairman of the BBC Trust, Lord Patten, who has said he is dedicated to getting to the bottom of the Jimmy Savile scandal that has engulfed the corporation, vowing there would be "no covering our backs".

  • Savile sex abuse investigation

    File photo dated 01/01/72 of DJ Jimmy Savile visiting the patients and staff of Leeds General Infirmary at the start of the new year. tHE Chairman of the BBC Trust, Lord Patten, has said he is dedicated to getting to the bottom of the Jimmy Savile scandal that has engulfed the corporation, vowing there would be "no covering our backs".

  • Savile sex abuse investigation

    File photo dated 27/10/2005 of Dame Janet Smith. An inquiry into the BBC's "culture and practices" during the era of star presenter Jimmy Savile's campaign of sexual abuse is to begin today.

  • Winterbourne View court case

    Bev Dawkins (third right) of Mencap reads a statement on behalf of the families who suffered abuse by 11 members of staff from the Winterbourne View care home who were caught on camera abusing severely disabled patients during an undercover BBC Panorama investigation at the South Gloucestershire private hospital.

  • Gary Glitter Arrested By Officers From 'Operation Yewtree'

    LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM - OCTOBER 28: Police officers leave the apartment of Paul Gadd, otherwise known as 'Gary Glitter' on October 28, 2012 in London, England. Police have arrested the former pop star and convicted sex offender as part of their investigation into allegations of sexual abuse by Jimmy Savile. (Photo by Warrick Page/Getty Images)

  • Culture, Media and Sport select committee

    BBC Director-General George Entwistle leaves Portcullis House in Westminster, London, after being quizzed about the corporation's handling of the Jimmy Savile sex abuse scandal by a committee of MPs.

  • Culture, Media and Sport select committee

    BBC Director-General George Entwistle (front left) and Head of BBC Editorial Policy David Jordan (front right) give evidence to the Culture, Media and Sport select committee in the House of Commons, London, on the corporation's handling of the Jimmy Savile sex abuse scandal.

  • Culture, Media and Sport select committee

    Head of BBC Editorial Policy David Jordan gives evidence to the Culture, Media and Sport select committee in the House of Commons, London, on the corporation's handling of the Jimmy Savile sex abuse scandal.

  • Culture, Media and Sport select committee

    BBC Director-General George Entwistle gives evidence to the Culture, Media and Sport select committee in the House of Commons, London, on the corporation's handling of the Jimmy Savile sex abuse scandal.

 

Follow Tim Knight on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TimKnight6

FOLLOW CANADA