Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Toula Foscolos

GET UPDATES FROM Toula Foscolos
 

Can Quebec Move Past its Teenage Angst?

Posted: 09/05/2012 4:16 pm

Sleep deprived, confused, conflicted, disoriented, defeated, in need of some perspective, and still cautiously optimistic. These are but some of the emotions I'm experiencing the day after what turned out to be a surreal ending to this month-long cacophony of campaign coverage.

First off, the results...proving, once again, that polls can provide nothing more than a skewed and imperfect glimpse into voters' intentions, Quebecers sat stunned in front of their TVs last night as the results started trickling in.

When it was all over but the crying, the Liberals, in their defeat, had paradoxically still pulled off a stunning victory; managing to snag 49 seats during a re-election campaign and a vocal student movement that had positioned them perfectly for vilification.

The PQ, on the other hand, had succeeded in forming a government, but only barely. Despite expectations from many that Pauline Marois and her party, armed with highly contentious proposed identity and language policies, would march victoriously towards a firm majority, all they succeeded in doing was barely cross the finish line. A slim 55-seat PQ minority, inevitably -- and perhaps bitterly to some hardliners -- also translates to a 68-seat strong opposition, and a firm rejection of sovereignty. Quebecers voted for change, yes. But they didn't necessarily vote for the PQ's policies. It's an election that was in many ways lost by Charest, not necessarily won by Marois.

The day after, there are no clear winners or losers. Quebecers gaze at a poisoned political landscape that seems to have borne bitter fruit. Satisfaction seems to elude us all -- irrelevant of our allegiances. Everything has been turned on its head; most of all, one suspects, the expectations of the older political parties.

Across Canada, panic has set in, as the ROC tries to analyze and predict what a PQ victory (albeit it, a minority one) might mean for the country's unity. Of course, most of the Quebec bashing, the angst, the fear comes from the fact that, unless you live here, you are unable to truly understand the delicate -- sometimes painful, always clumsy -- dance we engage in when language tensions get high.

The number of ROC journalists and pundits covering the elections last night speaks to Canada's desire to understand, but also its inability to do so. The confusion is such that it prompted Canadian comedian, Steve Patterson, to jokingly tweet that "English journalists who don't live in Quebec analyzing QC election results are as relevant as middle-aged men reviewing the Twilight series."

Fair enough, but sometimes even the English and French journalists who do live in Quebec miss the mark terribly. Perception has a way of altering reality to such a degree that it sometimes renders us unable to see clearly. All we have left are knee-jerk reactions. But here's some perspective the day after.

After it's all said and done, Quebecers went to the polls in record numbers and voted for change, yes. But most importantly, whether it was a conscious decision or not, they voted for forced collaboration. They not only rejected the status quo; they rejected the status quo in waiting. In doing so, they also rejected their rhetoric. They elected a pro-sovereignty minority PQ government that will have no choice but to work together with a strong opposition comprised of two pro-federalist parties.

This is no longer the Quebec of the Quiet Revolution. This province is willing to be loud about what it does and does not want. The problem is; it still needs to figure out what it is and what it isn't.

To paraphrase Shakespeare, this summer has been our summer of discontent. Students made their case with a pot-banging, marching symphony that left some covering their ears. Those sickened by allegations of rampant corruption wanted change. The phraseology involving religion and language became ugly. Politicians manipulated and harnessed this malaise to further their own goals, unwilling to accept the dangers such loaded parlance could unleash.

And then shots were fired. And we all collectively gasped and came to our senses. We all recoiled in horror at the stark difference between what we thought we were and the offensive zealots we could so easily become. Today, we hopefully all take a step back.

Most of what will be making the media rounds today will be the details of the bizarre assassination attempt on Marois' life. I'm refraining from focusing on this tragic event, because, while it's perhaps understandable (and, perhaps, even worthwhile) that people will want to ponder what implications one of the most hateful and polarizing campaigns I've seen in Quebec in a long time, had on the psyche of a mentally-ill man justifying such actions to himself, it's irrelevant. Ultimately, his personal actions have as much to do with the campaign's divisive rhetoric as video games and rock music have to do with creating mass murderers. Let's not fall into that trap. Let's focus on the real issues.

There's an existential crisis brewing. A province realizing it's not necessarily the open, welcoming, progressive place it thought it was; a people grappling with questions of identity, inclusiveness, and neurotic navel gazing. A new generation coming to terms with the inelegant phobias and fears it wants to unload, as it stumbles upon a new acceptance of what it wants to embrace.

Maybe some of you don't see it yet, but there's sweet comfort to be had in the chaos. This is a society in real flux. A society that is, in some ways, holding on to the last vestiges of a past that defined what it became, but can no longer allow it to become what it must. Quebec is experiencing major growing pains.

The ugly rhetoric and the overall nastiness of the campaign were, in many ways, indicative of anachronistic parties attempting to remain relevant. Relevant, in a time where, even as the hateful politics of division persist, they are slowly, but systematically, being thrust aside for a new vision of shared commonality, and mutual respect. It is the kind of global vision that positions Quebecers as proud members of a distinct society that embraces its uniqueness of culture and language, without living in constant trepidation. The kind of vision that led a Francophone colleague of mine to exclaim: "I want to raise my children to be proud; not afraid."
Feminist author Adrienne Rich once stated: "It's exhilarating to be alive in a time of awakening consciousness; it can also be confusing, disorienting, and painful."

Evolution like this is always raw, vexatious, and hurts to the touch. It's not pretty while it's taking place, because progress is always jerked violently back by those who can't understand or accept it, but if nurtured and allowed to take place, it can lead to the kind of evolution one hopes for.

For the first time in its history, Quebec has elected a woman premier. What's so outstanding about this is how little importance it merited in most of our media. It speaks to the fact that we have a society that naturally assumes that a woman can tackle the job. For the first time in a long time, we have a change of government. Democracy always needs a change of guard and an injection of new blood and ideas to operate well.

For the first time we have not one, but multiple pro-sovereignty parties emerging, signifying that there's a change in how this population perceives self-determination, and a new breed of Quebecer no longer attached to the ugly pandering of "nous" vs. "vous."

For the first time we have a forced coalition of power that will either have to find a way to work together or perish. This minority government won't survive a year if it's not prepared to compromise and add water to its hardline wine. Those are all good things.

While many worry that the current social climate in Quebec is a worrisome one, the fact that everything has been turned on its head may prove to be a good thing. It means we are now faced with a new perspective. Now it's up to us to create the kind of place that speaks to the people we claim we want to be. It's time for the hateful rhetoric, the ugly politics of division, and the manipulation of people's fears to be done with. It's time to look past the narrow confines of our own prejudices and shape our own narrative; not the one so conveniently dictated to us by the powers that be.

 

Follow Toula Foscolos on Twitter: www.twitter.com/toulastake

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
Sleep deprived, confused, conflicted, disoriented, defeated, in need of some perspective, and still cautiously optimistic. These are but some of the emotions I'm experiencing the day after what turned...
Sleep deprived, confused, conflicted, disoriented, defeated, in need of some perspective, and still cautiously optimistic. These are but some of the emotions I'm experiencing the day after what turned...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:32 PM on 09/07/2012
I look forward to seeing this gov't in action. I believe all parties realize, the one who refuses to play along will lose the next election. Quebecers, and all Canadians, are sick of politics. We want you to go away, do your jobs, and not p*ss us off.
09:13 AM on 09/08/2012
Personally, I am not sick of politics. I am sick of THEIR way of doing it. We need a proportional voting system! That's the only way to get out of this vicious cycle!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Parketkat
03:37 PM on 09/06/2012
"English journalists who don't live in Quebec analyzing QC election results are as relevant as middle-aged men reviewing the Twilight series."

so what this really means is no country, politicial or government anywhere has any right to speak about anywhere else on earth? That unless you live directly in the physical location of the issue, that individual could never possibly understand the issue? not sure I agree with that sentiment. if that is the case, all countries need to become isolationists. I am sorry, I love quebec but they ARE CANADIAN an they're no more special then the rest of us. If we deal and comment on things like Iran and Syria, we have every right to do so about our own provincial territories!
This comment has been removed.
02:49 AM on 09/06/2012
Quebeckers can start by realizing their battle for identity and cultural sustainability has already been won, and that they can be proud Canadians as well as proud Quebeckers. Quebec does not have to be at war with the federal government and a federal identity any more than any other province which looks to get a fair deal for its citizens WITHIN the federation.

Living in Northern Ontario I am in constant touch with francophones - friends and acquaintances - who identify themselves as Canadians first; francophones who are happy to live their lives as francophones and English-speaking interchangeably, without feeling that anyone is trying to make them feel second-class. They feel secure and self-confident, rather than being tinged with bitterness and replaying historical grievances. They have a true joie de vivre. These are the French-Canadians that I know and admire.
08:11 AM on 09/06/2012
I think that was well said!! I too come from the area and my experiences (from childhood to adulthood) have been an excellent example of how we all live together!! I think the powers that be should take notes and govern by the example!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Manu1
10:11 PM on 09/05/2012
ou know what this is called "Democracy".
Not everybody has to agree on everything. But everybody has to ACCEPT that others might not think the same. Respectfully.
08:47 PM on 09/05/2012
Great article, Tula. You are right on. While I am not totally sure what it will produce, this flux you are talking about is very strong and pretty unique in this continent. It feels great.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
07:52 PM on 09/05/2012
What? $1B Carbon Sequestration plant announced for the oil sands and zero coverage on the HP?

Golly, I wonder why?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
07:50 PM on 09/05/2012
Mass immigration is washing Quebec culture out to sea.

There will be nothing unique about Quebec in 40 years, save a few buildings, and a few people speaking a funny language in retirement homes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Manu1
10:07 PM on 09/05/2012
"a few people speaking a funny language" You know this is exactly that kind of despising remark that put Quebecers off: "a funny langusge"... english people wonder then why Quebecers seek to leave Canada.... English people then wonder why Quebecer feel humiliated and not respected over and over again.
I suppose you're proud to be a wonderful Canadian , full of puffy democratic and liberal ideals.
08:24 AM on 09/06/2012
Well, not everyone believes it to be a funny language...there are other Francophones living throughout Canada who do not feel humiliated and respected....there are many who love the diversity they bring without trying change who they are as individuals....or them trying to "enforce" or push their ideals onto anyone else....there are those who simply, at times, will "agree to disagree", or, who will enjoy trying communicate to each other...who realize that who they are, as individuals - in heritage and in culture - are seen to be just as valuable as anyone else...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Parketkat
05:09 PM on 09/06/2012
I think it's a chicken and egg scenario. Do the eglish make fun of quebec and therefore make quebecs want to leave? or does quebec make the rest of canada feel like nothing is ever good enough and so the english make fun? I remind you, you don't see many of us chiding france - it has nothing to do with your language - most of hte rest of us get along well wit chinese, south asians, muslims, hindus - pretty much every other culture on earth is welcome here. Its that quebec doesn't seem to embrace those same ideals and expects better treatment. I would also say we find it insulting that you feel quebec is only for the french. Immigrants helped build every part of htis country. I don't think its as simple as you've stated - it's a far more complex issue.
02:41 PM on 09/06/2012
It's really only an issue for Montreal. It's not like people are wandering around Abitibi saying "what's with all the immigrants?" Whereas walking down St. Catherine MTL street you'll pass someone from almost every country in the span of a block. We should say, yes Quebec has it's distinct culture, and put an asterisk next to Montreal, *international exception.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
07:49 PM on 09/05/2012
Mass immigration and multiculturalism will very quickly destroy any 'unique' components of Quebec culture. It has already destroyed any hope of common identity in the ROC.

It's not refreshing to watch the prose of shallow and naive fools who don't know what they want, and don't recognize what is happening to them.

I would rather Quebec separate from Canada and be a strong culture - than submit to the forces of cultural globalism that will wash it out to sea.
11:45 PM on 09/05/2012
Exactly what "common identity" would you claim for the ROC? Would it include Eastern Europeans, Irish, and Germans? Would it include Natives and Metis? Or are you just comfortable with the English/Scottish era?
06:21 PM on 09/05/2012
i love it. destroy the country, destroy harper. who cares? We are not worthy anymore of being respected. We are the lowest form of country on earth now. One that puts profit in front of people and the planet.
06:12 PM on 09/05/2012
This is the most compelling and honest article written on the current political and social climate we're in. Good job and bravo.