Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tracie Wagman

GET UPDATES FROM Tracie Wagman
 

Why Are Other Mothers So Judgemental?

Posted: 10/13/11 01:38 PM ET

Unless you're wearing a curly white wig and holding a gavel, please don't judge me. This is easier said than done, I know.

Mothers compare parenting skills. It's what we do. We glance at the mom scolding her child at the grocery store and think, "SHE has clearly has lost control of this situation." We eyeball the contents of school lunchboxes on the days we volunteer and think incredulously, "Seriously, she packed processed cheese on white bread?"

We judge strangers all the time. If you say you don't, think again. Have you ever silently "tsked, tsked" a mom at the park for losing it on her tantruming toddler? You don't know her story, but it's human nature to make snap judgments. I'm sure even Mother Theresa silently judged her Mother Superior on a bad day.

When it comes to close friends who understand our circumstances, we expect support, not judgment. I felt that sting recently when we finally, after a year-long search, settled on a new school for our daughter. My husband and I didn't take the decision to leave her current school lightly. We fretted and researched and second guessed ourselves. We visited 20 schools in an attempt to do what we thought was best for our child. When we found "the one," the perfect fit, we were relieved to be moving forward.

When I told some of the moms at our current school, their reaction threw me for a loop. I expected some disappointment, but didn't anticipate the harsh criticism. I was horrified. I was already insecure about my decision and their catty judgment was crippling. I questioned our decision and also myself. Did we make a mistake? Was my child going to be forever damaged by a choice we inflicted upon her?

I've come to realize that every parent is insecure about their own decisions; from whether to circumcise, to how much TV is ok. We agonize over these details and look for validation from our fellow moms. Clearly my decision to change schools made these mothers uneasy. Instead of, "We'll miss you, but we're excited about this new opportunity," perhaps they heard, "We're leaving you for something better." I don't know. I do know their judgment and verbal beating hurt.

It's normal human behaviour to make judgments. It's a crucial component to critical thinking and out of your control. What you do with these judgments, however, is completely within your control. Before you share your opinion, consider how your message will be perceived. Are you sincerely concerned and trying to help, or are you trying to justify your own choices by questioning somebody else's?

 

Follow Tracie Wagman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@HelpWeveGotKid

Unless you're wearing a curly white wig and holding a gavel, please don't judge me. This is easier said than done, I know. Mothers compare parenting skills. It's what we do. We glance at the mom sco...
Unless you're wearing a curly white wig and holding a gavel, please don't judge me. This is easier said than done, I know. Mothers compare parenting skills. It's what we do. We glance at the mom sco...
Around the Web:

Judgemental People

 
 
  • Comments
  • 22
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:10 AM on 10/16/2011
It is interesting to hear so many judgmental comments by women about Wagman's article - a case in point, I suppose. I believe that women judge each other's parenting so much because women are so insecure and guilt ridden about their own parenting, even when it is stellar. I have been quite surprised by how much guilt many mothers express at my parenting lectures. I wrote a book all about supporting parents' basic instincts, and hear mountains of guilt when I speak.

Mothers take mothering extremely seriously, worry they are doing it wrong, and measure themselves against other mothers. It seems that the best mothers judge themselves the most harshly. If mothers could feel more confident about their own gut instincts, perhaps there would be less judgment in general.

Sheri Noga, MA
www.grateful-child.com
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:49 PM on 10/14/2011
Wagman has way too much free time if she allows anyone to throw her ' for a loop' about anything that is none of anyone else's business. How does she decide what to wear without the input from 'moms at school'? I could understand her reaction if she was a young, single mother. In that instance she would need the support of her peer group.
My main question would be about how much of a 'bragger/showoff Wagman is with her 'peers'? Or does she 'act superior' even if it's out of her basic lack of confidence.Some women don't realize how they come across to others. I think she should put her head down and look after her own kids and stop inviting comments from people she doesn't want to hear from. People don't tend to comment when an individual sends a clear unspoken message that comments aren't welcome.
Wagman must have a lot to say about others to be treated this way by the mothers in the group.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
surfette72
Hang on tight Libs...we'll be back.
03:46 PM on 10/13/2011
"Why are other mothers so judgemental???" Oh please, women have always been judgemental of other women. I knew this when I was 11; there's no way I'm buying that this is suddenly "news." Perhaps it's the double standard created and perpepuated by the feminist movement, or simply conditioning by society. Women are somehow of the mindset that if they are a "woman" they can get away with anything. It's really sad. This "judgement" is the perfect prerequisite for the "mean girl" syndrome. Keep it up, ladies. See where it gets us.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:57 PM on 10/14/2011
Surfette ,these aren't teens they are grown,married women. They should be well past the 'mean girl' stage. 'Nasty B*tch' comes after 'mean girl' and one is able to side step them easily by absenting one's self from the NB's presence. Simply don't engage. Isn't there a time when we cast off the 'woman' designation and simply become an adult. God, I'm counting on it.
09:30 AM on 10/15/2011
The feminist movement? Really?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
surfette72
Hang on tight Libs...we'll be back.
10:21 AM on 10/15/2011
Yep! Really!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Daniel Hough Jones
02:45 PM on 10/13/2011
Dear Tracie,

I feel as though I have wandered into the wrong part of the department store.

I thought your post was thoughtful and sensitive - a brief meditation on your experiences. (I have two daughters and grandchildren.) Then I read some of the comments below from other woman.

I am a firm believer that women in general and mothers in particular need the companionship of other women - much more than our modern society allows (time pressures, commuting, etc.). But some of your commentators remind me that women can be very biting towards one another and the worst of enemies.

Well, anyway, I liked your post.

Best wishes,
Daniel Hough Jones
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Glass Cannon
Let every eye negotiate for itself.
01:05 PM on 10/13/2011
Perception is everything, after all. Don't ya know?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DianaLynn1967
It's a great life if you don't weaken!
01:14 AM on 10/13/2011
"It's normal human behaviour to make judgments. It's a crucial component to critical thinking and out of your control. What you do with these judgments, however, is completely within your control. Before you share your opinion, consider how your message will be perceived. Are you sincerely concerned and trying to help, or are you trying to justify your own choices by questioning somebody else's?"

This, right here, applies everywhere, not just in parenting.

I appears however that the majority of the readers (at least the ones who commented) missed the fact that you were trying to be humble by admitting your own judgmental qualities before expressing surprise at the judgments of your "friends." Oh well. My attitude toward both sets of judgmental parties would be "Frig 'em!" (Unfortunately, frigging is way too good for them.) It's your life and your kid's life, not theirs.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newshoundmama
My bite's worse than my bark
08:52 PM on 10/12/2011
Are you in high school? First, I can't imagine an adult being so caught up in what their peer group thinks of them. Nor can I imagine an adult who so blithely feels the need to examine the contents of a lunch bag of someone else's kid, simply to find something to pass judgement on. Perhaps you should pass judgement on your own incapacity to wonder if processed cheese on white bread is the healthiest, (pea)nut-free option she can send to the school and still be confident the kid will eat it without her there to ensure it is eaten. You post highlighted the ridiculous things you think are to be judged, and then you got your hackles up because your peers did much the same thing to you. Maybe you could be less obsessive about what school to send your kid to, and try spending a little time finding a peer group that doesn't try to cannibalize it's members. That is, if you figure you could learn to refrain from trying to convince yourself you're a better parent than everyone else around you. Good luck with that one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kelzie01
01:25 PM on 10/13/2011
Oh, the irony.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Helen In Canada
07:51 PM on 10/12/2011
Our first priority as moms should be our children's well-being, physically and emotionally. It's human nature to notice what other parents are doing with their kids - scolding and 'losing it' most certainly will command attention, as it should. Remember the phrase, 'it takes a village to raise a child'? It's a long-forgotten belief, but the primitive instinct to watch over our neighbours remains in many. The fact is, there ARE negligent and bad parents out there. We shouldn't let it slide because...oh, I don't know...we might offend the abusive parent. (!!!) That's all you see - that reflex in action. And I agree with the other posters...20 different schools???
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newshoundmama
My bite's worse than my bark
08:59 PM on 10/12/2011
When did scolding your children in a grocery store become abusive? The issues the author highlighted that she judges other parents on don't even come close to abuse. Scolding a misbehaving child is a parent's job, in private and (perhaps even more importantly) in public. Parents have an obligation to control their children's behaviour, and that does not mean meekly looking the otherway while the little darling acts obnoxiously, annoys those around them, and tries to manipulate control away from the parent. Not handling the situation immediately and decisively, and clearly is, in and of itself, negligent. It's fear of being judged that makes for ineffective and cowardly parents who expect the rest of the world to put up with their kids brattiness because they don't have enough vertabrae to handle their kids.
04:58 PM on 10/12/2011
Let me adjust the title of this article to appropriately address the problem: Why Are Women So Judgmental?

And, learn how to spell judgmental.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WilliamL
07:57 PM on 10/12/2011
A heads up to the editors would have been enough.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:49 PM on 10/12/2011
Both forms of spelling are correct and accepted in different English-speaking countries.
03:42 PM on 10/12/2011
Hi! Every child is different as well as every parent. What works for one child/parent may not work for another. In our family we tend to ignore what others are doing and just do what works well for us. There is too little time in the day to be critical of others.

Thanks for the post. Have a great day!

Cheers,
Louise
Bianca S
You can't go trick-or-treating. Ever. For a week
02:54 PM on 10/12/2011
At the risk of being "that woman", the author sounds like one of those super competitive (TWENTY schools, really? I didn't even research 20 universities for gosh sakes), controlling 'helicopter' parents that are the exact reason why parents, mothers especially, are so judgmental and competitive in the first place; "Well, I'm sure your school is good enough for your child, but it's just not good enough for MINE. But I just don't know why everyone is so judgmental of me!" Please.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MissTake1989
Equal means equal, hypocrites.
04:40 PM on 10/12/2011
Exactly right.

Her entire article is about how judgmental and jealous everyone else is at what a great, caring and devoted mother she is...(insert back-patting here).

Meanwhile, she's insecure to the point where I think she might want to talk to someone a few time a week.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
great, green, globs of greasy grimey GOPerspeak.
07:07 PM on 10/12/2011
I have to agree with the reaction to searching for a year through 20 schools seems a bit obsessive or indecisive unless her child has a particularly difficult to meet special needs from a learning disability. Telling the other Moms and not expecting feedback is unrealistic. She just didn't like the feedback she got. I guess she only wants positive feedback. Writing an article about how mean the moms were to her is just another attempt at getting validation for her decision to move her child and a pat on the back for her sacrifice.