Hockey Night in Canada, which celebrates its 60th anniversary this year, is by far the network's most watched show. When the lockout-truncated 2013 season got underway last January, audience numbers reached record peaks of more than three million viewers. Playoff audiences have topped five million.
NHL hockey is also the network's biggest money-spinner, bringing in an annual haul of about $100 million, roughly a third of total CBC advertising revenue.
Many other public broadcasters carry professional sports. The BBC, for example, spends just under one-tenth of its public subsidy on sports rights. It justifies the expense by arguing that:
• Major sporting events can bring communities, and the nation, together;
• Minority and public service sports coverage brings communities of interest together and broadens cultural horizons, and;
• Sports broadcasts serve audiences that are otherwise under-served by the public broadcaster, such as young men, lower income and ethnic minority audiences.
Despite all of this, the CBC has no choice but to abandon HNC. Here's why.
Like the BBC, in a normal (non-Olympic) year CBC/Radio-Canada spends about one-tenth of its total revenue on sports, about $150 million. Most of this goes to NHL hockey and the long-running Hockey Night in Canada. The exact amount CBC pays to the NHL for broadcast rights is a closely-guarded secret, but insiders estimate it at $100 million. Add to that approximate production expenses of $25 million a year for a total of $125 million outlay for HNC. And according to Canadian Media Research Inc.'s Barry Kiefl, a former CBC research director, at least another $20 million should be added to account for the cost of selling the advertising.
So: revenue = $100 million; expenses = an estimated $145 million. Hockey produces a substantial net loss.
Hockey accounts for up to 400 hours of CBC television programming (Canadian content!) during the October-May season. Considering the rationale for broadcasting pro sports as summarized by the BBC, it could be argued that 400 hours is not a disproportionate allocation of time. The CBC could well claim that this is what it takes to engage those young men, low-income earners and ethnic minorities it would otherwise fail to reach.
Note, however, that while the BBC is able to spread its sports coverage over two television channels (BBC 1 and 2) , its Radio 5 live news and sports outlet, and its online services, CBC's sports programming is confined to its one English-language television channel and CBC.ca. (Radio-Canada relinquished French-language NHL rights hockey to the private cable sports outlet RDS, in 2001.)
The result on CBC television is that NHL hockey alone takes up a whopping 40 per cent of the prime time schedule between October and May. It's hard to see this as anything other than a serious programming imbalance.
And of course, there are other programming genres that could effectively engage low income and ethnic minority audiences -- though perhaps not young men. The BBC and other public broadcasters have addressed this issue not simply with sports, but with drama (Eastenders) and other program genres (Top Gear) that appeals to and reflects the lives of those demographics.
If CBC were to relinquish its NHL hockey rights to a private network, say, CTV, there is no reason why Canadians everywhere should not be able to continue to enjoy the sport on television. The various subscription sports specialty channels already broadcast three times as many NHL games as CBC (mostly American-vs.-American teams). The conventional terrestrial free-to-air private networks, which are also on basic cable, are technically capable of handling these productions.
One potential problem is that the commercial networks do not have the ubiquity of coverage, especially in the north, that CBC has attained and is mandated to provide. This is an issue that could be addressed through a CRTC regulation insisting that where private broadcasters of important sporting events cannot reach a specific audience, the CBC be given broadcast rights in that geographic area. There is ample precedent for this kind of co-operative arrangement throughout the history of broadcasting in Canada.
To protect Canadian viewers from the siphoning of important sports events to expensive subscription-only specialty channels (where producers glean revenue from both advertisements and subscription fees), the CRTC would once again have to intervene. Once again, however, there is ample precedent for this.
In the U.K., broadcast regulations stipulate that "listed" events deemed to be of national interest -- the FA World Cup, Wimbledon, Olympics, the Grand National and others -- must be offered to the BBC and/or must be made available without subscription fee to all Britons. These are called by the BBC "events of national resonance that bring the nation together."
Another grouping of sports events for which the BBC regularly purchases broadcast rights includes such spectacles as the British swimming championships, European gymnastics, motorcycle grand prix, Ascot, and the world darts championship. These are deemed to justify their cost by "driving audience value," and in some cases are of little interest to commercial, terrestrial free-to-air networks.
(The BBC, like all European Union public broadcasters, has in recent years been required to justify its expenditures on sports programming within the context of the wider broadcasting market. That is, they must demonstrate that in bidding for broadcast rights, they are not unfairly competing with their commercial counterparts by, for example, bidding up prices or monopolizing key rights.)
In an ideal world, the CBC, like the BBC, would have the funding and the additional radio, television and online outlets to enable it to continue to broadcast professional sport, including the Olympic Games (these days only technically "amateur" in nature). Given the real-world constraints under which the public broadcaster currently operates, however, a choice has to be made between carrying pro sport -- which can only be paid for with advertising revenue -- and having an advertising-free CBC.
In my view, the CBC simply cannot survive so long as it continues to rely on commercial sponsorship, and thereby makes itself essentially indistinguishable from its commercial competitors -- indistinguishable, and therefore irrelevant and unnecessary.
And so, NHL hockey has to go.
If it is true that by carrying NHL hockey the CBC is "bringing communities, and the nation, together," it will be unfortunate if the corporation has to abandon this opportunity in order to serve the greater purpose of becoming a true public broadcaster, one whose first priority is to serve citizens rather than advertisers.
But there's a silver lining. If and when private, commercial networks take on NHL hockey exclusively -- and if they are forced to provide key "listed" games via free-to-air and basic cable outlets -- they will be fulfilling a part of their obligations under the Broadcast Act that they have been neglecting for decades. That is, the obligation to provide genuine public service to the nation. In their current de facto role as re-broadcasters of American programming to Canadian audiences, with Canadian commercials inserted, they serve no such purpose.
Philadelphia Eagles' DeSean Jackson celebrates in the snow after a touchdown during the second half of an NFL football game against the Detroit Lions, Sunday, Dec. 8, 2013, in Philadelphia. (AP Photo/Matt Rourke)
Auburn cornerback Chris Davis (11) returns a missed field-goal attempt 109 yards to score the game-winning touchdown as time expired in the fourth quarter of an NCAA college football game against No. 1 Alabama in Auburn, Ala., Saturday, Nov. 30, 2013. Auburn won 34-28. (AP Photo/Dave Martin)
Portugal's Cristiano Ronaldo celebrates after scoring the 2-3 goal during the World Cup 2014 qualifying playoff second leg soccer match between Sweden and Portugal at Friends Arena in Stockholm, Tuesday, Nov. 19, 2013. (AP/TT/Pontus Lundahl) SWEDEN OUT
BOSTON, MA - NOVEMBER 02: The World Series trophy and the 'Boston Strong 617' jersey sit on the finish line of the Boston Marathon on Boylston Street during the World Series victory parade on November 2, 2013 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Jared Wickerham/Getty Images)
CLEMSON, SC - OCTOBER 19: Jameis Winston #5 of the Florida State Seminoles throws a pass as Vic Beasley #3 of the Clemson Tigers tries to stop him during their game at Memorial Stadium on October 19, 2013 in Clemson, South Carolina. (Photo by Streeter Lecka/Getty Images)
LOS ANGELES, CA - OCTOBER 29: Kobe Bryant of the Los Angeles Lakers reacts to someone in the crowd during the game against the Los Angeles Clippers at Staples Center on October 29, 2013 in Los Angeles, California. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and or using this photograph, User is consenting to the terms and conditions of the Getty Images License Agreement. (Photo by Jeff Gross/Getty Images)
SAN FRANCISCO, CA - JANUARY 12: Quarterback Colin Kaepernick #7 of the San Francisco 49ers celebrates after running in a touchdown in the first quarter against the Green Bay Packers during the NFC Divisional Playoff Game at Candlestick Park on January 12, 2013 in San Francisco, California. (Photo by Harry How/Getty Images)
Crowds greet Britain's Andy Murray as he celebrates with the trophy on the balcony of Centre Court after winning the Men's singles title on during day thirteen of the Wimbledon Championships at The All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club, Wimbledon, London, Sunday July 7, 2013. (AP Photo/Dominic Lipinski, PA) UNITED KINGDOM OUT NO SALES NO ARCHIVE
CORRECTS ID OF UMPIRE TO JIM JOYCE, INSTEAD OF ADAM WAINWRIGHT - St. Louis Cardinals catcher Yadier Molina looks back as home plate umpire Jim Joyce calls Boston Red Sox's Jonny Gomes safe on a three-run double by Shane Victorino during the third inning of Game 6 of baseball's World Series on Wednesday, Oct. 30, 2013, in Boston. At rear from left are Boston's Jacoby Ellsbury, Xander Bogaerts and David Ortiz. (AP Photo/Elise Amendola)
Horses make their way around turn one during the 139th Kentucky Derby at Churchill Downs Saturday, May 4, 2013, in Louisville, Ky. (AP Photo/Darron Cummings)
TAMPA, FL - JANUARY 01: Defensive end Jadeveon Clowney #7 of the South Carolina Gamecocks stretches for a fourth-quarter fumble during a 33 - 28 victory against the Michigan Wolverines in the Outback Bowl January 1, 2013 at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Florida. (Photo by Al Messerschmidt/Getty Images)
Indiana Pacers' Roy Hibbert (55) blocks the shot of New York Knicks' Carmelo Anthony, right, during the second half of Game 6 of an Eastern Conference semifinal NBA basketball playoff series on Saturday, May 18, 2013, in Indianapolis. The Pacers defeated the Knicks 106-99 to win the series 4-2. (AP Photo/Darron Cummings)
BOSTON, MA - OCTOBER 13: Boston police officer Steve Horgan reacts as Torii Hunter #48 of the Detroit Tigers tries to catch a grand slam hit by David Ortiz #34 of the Boston Red Sox in the eighth inning of Game Two of the American League Championship Series at Fenway Park on October 13, 2013 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images)
Paris Saint-Germain's Swedish forward Zlatan Ibrahimovic (C) kicks the ball to score during the French L1 football match Paris Saint Germain (PSG) against Bastia (SCB) on October 19, 2013 at the Parc des Princes in Paris. AFP PHOTO / LIONEL BONAVENTURE (Photo credit should read LIONEL BONAVENTURE/AFP/Getty Images)
Connecticut forward Kaleena Mosqueda-Lewis (23) goes after a rebound during first half of the national championship game against Louisville at the women's Final Four of the NCAA college basketball tournament, Tuesday, April 9, 2013, in New Orleans. (AP Photo/Gerald Herbert)
Jamaica's Usain Bolt (L) wins the100 metres final at the 2013 IAAF World Championships at the Luzhniki stadium in Moscow on August 11, 2013 while a lightning strikes in the sky. AFP PHOTO / OLIVIER MORIN
Manchester United's Dutch striker Robin van Persie (C) scores the opening goal during the English Premier League football match between Swansea City and Manchester United at Liberty Stadium in Swansea, south Wales, on August 17, 2013. AFP PHOTO/IAN KINGTON == RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR LIVE SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 45 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS. == (Photo credit should read IAN KINGTON/AFP/Getty Images)
Milwaukee Brewers' Carlos Gomez ducks out of the way as teammate Ryan Braun (8) tries to dunk him with water after a baseball game against the San Francisco Giants Wednesday, April 17, 2013, in Milwaukee. The Brewers won 4-3. (AP Photo/Morry Gash)
In this Monday, April 15, 2013 photo, former New England Patriots player Joe Andruzzi carries a woman from the scene of two blasts at the finish line of the Boston Marathon on Exeter Street in Boston. The bombs that ripped through the crowd at the Boston Marathon, killing three people and wounding more than 170, were fashioned out of pressure cookers and packed with metal shards, nails and ball bearings to inflict maximum carnage, a person briefed on the investigation said Tuesday. (AP Photo/The Boston Globe, Bill Greene) MANDATORY CREDIT, BOSTON HERALD OUT, QUINCY OUT, NO SALES, MAGS OUT
Michigan guard Trey Burke (3) walks off the court as Louisville celebrate their win during the second half of the NCAA Final Four tournament college basketball championship game Monday, April 8, 2013, in Atlanta. Louisville won 82-76. (Charlie Neibergall / AP)
Athletes start the New Zealand Ironman on March 2, 2013 in Taupo, New Zealand. (Phil Walter / Getty Images)
AP10ThingsToSee - U.S. swimmer Diana Nyad, 64, greets her support team before her swim to Florida from Havana, Cuba, Saturday, Aug. 31, 2013. Endurance athlete Nyad launched another bid Saturday to set an open-water record by swimming from Havana to the Florida Keys without a protective shark cage. (AP Photo/Ramon Espinosa, File)
Russia's Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova casts a shadow while serving to Switzerland's Romina Oprandi during their Portugal Open semifinal tennis match Friday, May 3 2013, in Oeiras, outside Lisbon. Pavlyuchenkova defeated Oprandi 0-6, 6-3, 6-1. (Armando Franca / AP)
Stanford players dump water over head coach Lele Forood's head as she gives an interview to Dave Kozlowski in the NCAA division 1 women's team tennis championship at the Khan Outdoor Tennis Complex Tuesday, May 21, 2013 on the University of Illinois campus in Urbana, Ill. Stanford defeated Texas A&M 4-3. (Stephen Haas / AP)
This screen image taken from NASA shows the Sochi Olympic torch being held during a spacewalk on Saturday, Nov. 9, 2013. Video streamed by the US space agency NASA showed Oleg Kotov and Sergei Ryazanskiy carrying the unlit Olympic torch, bobbing weightlessly at the end of a tether in a darkness dotted by stars. The two gingerly maneuvered to take photos of the torch against the background of the planet, the orbs edge glowing with sunrise. (AP Photo/NASA)
CARSON, CA - MAY 26: Robbie Rogers (L) #14 of Los Angeles Galaxy comes into the game for Juninho #19 in the second half against the Seattle Sounders FC at The Home Depot Center on May 26, 2013 in Carson, California. The Galaxy defeated Sounders FC 4-0. (Photo by Jeff Gross/Getty Images)
Belgium's RSC Anderlecht coach John Van Den Brom, center, after winning the final soccer match of the Belgian League against SV Zulte Waregem at the Constant Vanden Stock stadium in Brussels, Sunday, May 19, 2013. (Yves Logghe / AP)
Floyd Mayweather Jr. lands a left jab against Robert Guerrero in the fourth round during a WBC welterweight title fight, Saturday, May 4, 2013, in Las Vegas. (Isaac Brekken / AP)
Saudi Al-Hilal club player Nawaf Shaker celebrates after scoring a goal against Qatar's Al-Rayyan club during their AFC Champions League football match in Doha, Qatar, Tuesday, April 30, 2013. (Osama Faisal / AP)
Oakland Athletics' Eric Sogard gets a shaving cream pie in the face from Josh Reddick, rear, after Sogard scored the winning run on a sacrifice bunt from Coco Crisp during 10th inning of a baseball game against the Baltimore Orioles, Sunday, April 28, 2013, in Oakland. Calif. Oakland won 9-8. (Marcio Jose Sanchez / AP)
Fans try to catch a bat that Arizona Diamondbacks' Cody Ross lost on his swing during the first inning of a baseball game against the San Francisco Giants, Tuesday, April 30, 2013, in Phoenix. (Matt York / AP)
A worker grooms away tracks after an alligator crossed through a sand trap on the 14th hole during the first round of the PGA Tour Zurich Classic golf tournament at TPC Louisiana in Avondale, La., Thursday, April 25, 2013. (Gerald Herbert / AP)
Philadelphia Phillies center fielder Ben Revere dives for a fly out by St. Louis Cardinals' Carlos Beltran during the first inning of a baseball game, Saturday, April 20, 2013, in Philadelphia. (Matt Slocum / AP)
In this photo made with a fisheye lens, Kevin Harvick celebrates winning the Toyota Owners 400 NASCAR Sprint Cup Series auto race Saturday, April 27, 2013, at Richmond International Raceway in Richmond, Va. (Jared C. Tilton / AP)
Sunderland's manager Paolo Di Canio, celebrates after Stephane Sessegnon scores his goal during their English Premier League soccer match against Newcastle United at St James' Park, Newcastle, England, Sunday, April 14, 2013. (Scott Heppell / AP)
New York Yankees relief pitcher Mariano Rivera, left, laughs with former New York Mets closer John Franco after Franco caught Rivera's ceremonial first pitch before an interleague baseball game at Citi Field in New York, Tuesday, May 28, 2013. (Kathy Willens / AP)
San Diego Padres' Carlos Quentin charges into Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Zack Greinke after being hit by a pitch in the sixth inning of baseball game in San Diego, Thursday, April 11, 2013. (Lenny Ignelzi / AP)
Minnesota Twins' Brian Dozier, left, flips over after making a catch of a shallow fly ball off the bat of Los Angeles Angels' Peter Bourjos as right fielder Chris Parmelee watches in the first inning of a baseball game, Tuesday, April 16, 2013, in Minneapolis. (Jim Mone / AP)
Chicago Bulls forward Carlos Boozer reacts after a dunk during the second half of an NBA basketball game against the Detroit Pistons in Chicago, Sunday, March 31, 2013. The Bulls won 95-94. (Nam Y. Huh / AP)
Baylor's Brittney Griner gestures as she answers a question during a news conference for a regional semifinal in the women's NCAA college basketball tournament in Oklahoma City, Saturday, March 30, 2013. Baylor is scheduled to play Louisville Sunday. (Sue Ogrocki / AP)
Washington Nationals catcher Wilson Ramos loses the ball as New York Yankees' Eduardo Nunez slides safely into home with home plate umpire Adam Hamari looking on at right during the fourth inning of an exhibition baseball game at Nationals Park Friday, March 29, 2013, in Washington. (Alex Brandon / AP)
A young fan with his face painted with the colors of Chile's national flag gestures before the start of a 2014 World Cup qualifying soccer match against Uruguay in Santiago, Chile, Tuesday, March 26, 2013. (Victor R. Caivano / AP)
Serena Williams reacts after winning a point against Dominika Cibulkova, of Slovakia, during the Sony Open tennis tournament, Monday, March 25, 2013, in Key Biscayne, Fla. Williams won 2-6, 6-4, 6-2. (Lynne Sladky / AP)
Austria's Wolfgang Loitzl soars through the air during his competition jump of the third stage of the four hills ski jumping tournament during foggy weather in Innsbruck, Austria, Friday, Jan. 4, 2013. (Matthias Schrader, AP)
Sweden's skip Margaretha Sigfridsson shouts during her gold medal game against Scotland at the 2013 world women's curling championship in Riga, Latvia, Sunday, March 24, 2013. (Roman Koksarov / AP)
Philadelphia Phillies center fielder Ben Revere makes a diving catch of Will Middlebrooks's seventh-inning fly ball in a spring training baseball game against the Boston Red Sox in Clearwater, Fla., Sunday, March 24, 2013. (Kathy Willens / AP)
Texas A&M's Johnny Manziel, right, celebrates a touchdown by teammate Ben Malena (1) during the first quarter of an NCAA college football game against Rice, Saturday, Aug. 31, 2013, in College Station, Texas. Manziel has been suspended for the first half of the team's game for what the school said was an "inadvertent" violation of NCAA rules by signing autographs. (AP Photo/Eric Gay)
North Carolina coach Roy Williams cheers on his team during the second half of a second-round game against Villanova in the NCAA college basketball tournament Friday, March 22, 2013, in Kansas City, Mo. (Charlie Riedel / AP)
North Carolina's Dexter Strickland (1) and Reggie Bullock (35) stretch before practice for a second-round game of the NCAA college basketball tournament, Thursday, March 21, 2013, in Kansas City, Mo. North Carolina is scheduled to play Villanova Friday. (Charlie Riedel / AP)
Michigan State guard Denzel Valentine (45) grabs a rebound over Valparaiso guard Matt Kenney (23) in the first half of a second-round game of the NCAA college basketball tournament in Auburn Hills, Mich., Thursday March 21, 2013. (Paul Sancya / AP)
Lotus driver Kimi Raikkonen, left, of Finland, Ferrari's Fernando Alonso, center, of Spain and Red Bull's Sebastian Vettel of Germany celebrate on the podium after the Australian Formula One Grand Prix at Albert Park in Melbourne, Australia, Sunday, March 17, 2013. Raikonen won the race with Alonso second and Vettel third. (Andrew Brownbill / AP)
Follow Wade Rowland on Twitter: www.twitter.com/waderowland