Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Werner Patels

GET UPDATES FROM Werner Patels
 

The Liberals Deserve Better Than Justin

Posted: 01/04/2013 11:15 am

If Justin Bieber were a nobody and you'd met him in the street or at a bar, you might be inclined, provided he's your type, to ask him, "Wanna hang out sometime?", or, more awkwardly, "For you, I'd change the alphabet and put U and I next to each other." (Yeah, good luck with that.)

But Justin Bieber isn't a nobody. Girls, and some guys, scream and literally faint if they get within a few feet of their idol. This has nothing to do with his looks, but with the persona his fans have created of him because of his music and performance.

Whether you like him or not, Bieber has accomplished something, other than sporting the first name Justin and being his father's son.

On the other hand, Canada's other Justin, last name Trudeau, seems to think that his name and looks are enough. Unless he himself had a hand in his conception and birth, being his father's son is no great accomplishment. His looks, well, are a product of said conception and birth, and again not Justin's doing.

Yet so convinced is Justin of his birth right to become Liberal leader and, perhaps, prime minister, that he apparently deems working out a platform and policies as beneath him. I suppose such inconvenient grunt work is best left to the other leadership contenders and, generally, lesser beings.

Here's a question, then: How can Canadians (and since all Canadians are now eligible to elect the leader of the Liberal Party, it is only fair to ask this) be expected to arrive at an informed decision after several rounds of leadership debates if one candidate (particularly the "Chosen One") answers all questions from the media and other candidates by saying the equivalent of, "I don't know, but isn't my hair great?"

Stephen Harper has never been a very charismatic individual. But, whether you agree or disagree with him, he's an ideas man and a strategist. Probably the biggest factor in the Conservatives winning the 2006 election was Harper's clear and succinct roadmap to a handful of things he'd do if elected.

With such a checklist in hand, voters were able to get a good picture of what a Harper government might look like, and, above all, the program was easy to understand. (Note that this doesn't mean that Harper has been very good at implementing some of those ideas, but that's an entirely different story.)

Now fast forward again to the present day. Here we have a leadership hopeful who can't figure out what he wants to stand for (gun registry yes/no, support Quebec separatists yes/no, Albertans, good people yes/no, etc.).

Doesn't the Liberal Party deserve better? As the third-ranked party in the House of Commons, shouldn't the party do everything in its power to reconnect not only with Canadians but also with the many Liberal voters who have abandoned the party since 2005?

The answer to these questions is: yes, indeed.

So, how can the party pull this off?

Voters like ideas, as the last three elections have shown. This is how Canadians are reeled in, with easy-to-grasp and well-reasoned ideas. They love debating ideas, or at least enjoy listening to others debate them.

But it seems that if Justin T. has his druthers, there won't be anything in the ideas department. He, or his advisers, will figure things out once he's been crowned, er, elected party leader. And even then, he may well decide to keep all of that policy stuff under wraps until after he's taken up residence at 24 Sussex Drive.

So, what exactly does he expect the leadership race, and any subsequent election, to be? A beauty pageant? Are we going to stop talking about the economy, taxes, pensions and healthcare and instead turn our full attention to baton-twirling and swimsuit competitions?

This approach to politics may "work" in some parts of the world, but in Canada?

Suffice it to say that, should Justin climb to the top of the Liberal Mount Olympus, both Harper and Thomas Mulcair will make mincemeat out of him in the televised debates.

Oh well, as long as he keeps looking gorgeous, none of that really matters, right?

Loading Slideshow...

 

Follow Werner Patels on Twitter: www.twitter.com/WernerPatels

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
If Justin Bieber were a nobody and you'd met him in the street or at a bar, you might be inclined, provided he's your type, to ask him, "Wanna hang out sometime?", or, more awkwardly, "For you, I'd ch...
If Justin Bieber were a nobody and you'd met him in the street or at a bar, you might be inclined, provided he's your type, to ask him, "Wanna hang out sometime?", or, more awkwardly, "For you, I'd ch...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 71
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
05:42 AM on 01/20/2013
If Justin can become half as good as his father was he can quite easily demolish the current field of candidates. His father was formidable as a debater and strategic thinker not withstanding his love for women. Oh the glory days watching Pierre Trudeau bring parliament to its knees. Justin you can too, go study your fathers tapes while in parliamentary sessions. Good luck Justin, you have the charisma and the genes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ProgressiveCDN
A Progressive Moderate
11:18 AM on 01/07/2013
What nonsense! First of all, I've never heard Justin promote his own hair. I'm pretty sure that's just women in the media, and some males who apparently fawn over this fact (like yourself)... Also, he clearly apologized for the 2010 Alberta statement and has never said a bad thing about all Albertans in general.

Trudeau took a very controversial stance on the Nexxen deal.. He's also openly supported the oil sands expansion, though he opposes the Northern Gateway pipeline. So, he has taken stances and he has many ideas if you actually listen to him.. Right now, as a leadership candidate, these ideas are broad without specific policy but that is expected. This IS a leadership election, not a national election, so all the points you make about Harper's "ideas" are null and void. Considering I, and most Canadians, don't even remember Harper's leadership election..

Your fear for this young, charismatic & pragmatic politician is incredibly transparent. I can hardly wait for our new leader! :D
photo
Voltage
You can't spell Canada without "eh."
04:48 PM on 01/06/2013
The Sun is already attacking him relentlessly (while childishly insulting both father and son). I take this to mean that the right is pretty afraid of him. If he's elected the Lib leader, that's reason enough for me to vote for him.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Werner Patels
01:30 PM on 01/07/2013
Cutting off one's nose to spite one's face? ....
photo
Natural Dog
I'll need another pint
01:53 PM on 01/06/2013
The only people who have already elected (crowned) Justin Trudeau as the Liberal leader are pundits scrambling for something to write about.

Most of us on the left do not see him as a shoo-in because of his surname, and at least no less than those on the right who will dismiss him out of hand simply because of his surname.

I would suggest that Mr. Patels give Justin the opportunity to present his case to the party, then they will decide if he is worthy.

Sophomoric rants and jibes about his hair and how handsome he is tend to make one believe that the right is more concerned about Justin Trudeau than they let on.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Werner Patels
01:30 PM on 01/07/2013
Point well taken, thank you.
photo
TT Esty1
Failure is a temporary condition.
08:41 PM on 01/05/2013
Sometimes a young sapling survives the storms easier than a mighty oak.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Werner Patels
01:31 PM on 01/07/2013
I think this is what we're all afraid of in this case...
07:02 PM on 01/05/2013
Was there not a time when the Conservatives failed to release their election platform until a WEEK before Canadians went to the polls?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gustav Hotch
Don't worry...be happy !
10:10 AM on 01/05/2013
JT said that Quebec independancy is allright,then a few days later he said that 's not what he meant..so what does he mean exactly ?Naaaaaaaahhh we don't need a playboy figure to run the country.
photo
Natural Dog
I'll need another pint
01:54 PM on 01/06/2013
moronic post
01:49 AM on 01/05/2013
Justin was never a mover or shaker in the HOC either. I think that no matter how much you point out to Canadians how shallow his talents are they will vote for him anyway because of his star power. It's what it is these days.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Werner Patels
01:32 PM on 01/07/2013
"Star power" over substance? Sad, but true... not good for Canada, though.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:51 AM on 01/05/2013
Blame the citizens people love JT and don't even know why. Most of it is simply a blind hatred of Stephen Harper and his government. JT is the well known pretty nice guy that contrasts against the cold calculated Harper. Problem is the Liberals have pulled to far to the left, JT recognizes this (thus his comments on the gun registry) and is trying to center the ship but doesn't want to make that known to prevent losing votes during the liberal convention. We get the same crap in Toronto half the city says it would for sure vote for Olivia Chow despite the fact she hasn't declared or even mentioned any substantial policy.
01:39 PM on 01/05/2013
"blind hatred of Stephen Harper and his government" read a newspaper and you might understand where his "blind hate" comes from.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:01 PM on 01/05/2013
It's not about why people hate Harper my point is they get on the anyone but Harper bandwagon and it allows JT to avoid having to make tough decisions. By all means if you hate Harper vote against him but the person who replaces him should have a clear vision for the country.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Werner Patels
01:33 PM on 01/07/2013
As I always say, voting AGAINST someone or something is detrimental to democracy. People need to start voting FOR someone or something again.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:56 PM on 01/07/2013
I agree completely, blind faith is for cults rational people ask for details and facts. 
02:19 PM on 01/08/2013
That's how we got saddled with Harper governments: people voting against the Liberal party because the whole party (as individuals, overall no more or less honest than the electorate are overall) had its reputation smeared with the corruption of a few individuals on the *edges* of the party.
07:37 PM on 01/04/2013
Actually Werner the Price Arthur Herald deserves better.
photo
sdbest
Film producer, activist
05:36 PM on 01/04/2013
Given what I've seen of Justin Trudeau on television and in the emails I've received from his campaign, I doubt he'd be able to survive the scrutiny and bare knuckle partisan exchanges of a national campaign. Unlike Harper, Mulcair, and May, Trudeau has little grasp of the issues. And, as Patel suggested, apart from "Being Justin" he seems to lack any real interest in matters of substance or policy. Justin doesn't seem to want to be Prime Minister, but rather Prime Cheerleader and, maybe, the Prom King.

It seems to me the wrong Trudeau son entered politics. Alexandre "Sacha" Trudeau, Justin's younger brother, has proven himself even in war zones, to be engaged, intelligent, informed, and man of principle and courage. I suspect Alexandre could be the person that Justin's fans think there hero is. Justin is Margaret's son; Alexandre is Pierre's.

At any rate, if Trudeau becomes the leader of the Liberal Party, Justin's fans and the Liberal Party faithful, I fear, are in for a rude disappointment. Trudeau's failings will be revealed most starkly, most cringingly during the televised debates which will be between two men, a woman, and a boy. As Trudeau's weaknesses become achingly and embarrassingly apparent on live television, his fans will abandon him as quickly as they attached themselves to him, such is fandom, and that will be the end of the once great Liberal Party of Canada.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Werner Patels
01:34 PM on 01/07/2013
Let's hope you're right and that Justin will find a job he's better suited for.
This comment has been removed.
05:16 PM on 01/04/2013
you are old and back dated my friend. He is what we need
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Werner Patels
01:36 PM on 01/07/2013
Old? Justin is just a few years younger... What we need is ideas and strong policies, neither of which we have seen from Justin (nor do I think we ever will).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
03:36 PM on 01/04/2013
Sorry Justin Trudeau will bring the Liberal Party up from the grave who Harper sent there. If the Liberals want to regain their status Justin Trudeau is your man. Unless you want a the ultimate Harper Victory which would be a NDP government.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Werner Patels
01:36 PM on 01/07/2013
Personally, I'd rather see a PM Mulcair than PM Trudeau.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
03:17 PM on 01/07/2013
So I'm guessing Liberals want Harper to Win? A NDP government will be Harper victory. For example why was Jack Layton given a state funeral when past Liberal leaders who never made PM never got one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ergon
Man From Atlan
03:16 PM on 01/04/2013
We certainly deserve better journalism than this, but there you have it. A better subject might be,  why are Canadians so excited about Justin Trudeau running for the office? 

You might also want to hold off on your predictions about how he'll do during question period. As a certain conservative senator found out recently, it won't be easy  to make 'mincemeat' of Justin Trudeau :)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Werner Patels
03:49 PM on 01/04/2013
Sorry that you feel slighted by criticism of your "star" and "idol" Justin, but it's just an honest and objective observation (i.e., without any axe to grind): Those who push him don't have the best interests of the Liberal Party or Canada at heart.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ergon
Man From Atlan
05:25 PM on 01/04/2013
Note the heavy use of sarcasm and quotation marks. Journalism 101 much? But thank you for your opinion.