Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Yoni Goldstein
 

One Kind of Racism is Not Like the Other

Posted: 03/23/2012 1:21 am

The majority of Canadians are racist toward Muslims. That's the gist of a countrywide poll released earlier this week. The Léger Marketing survey shows that 52 per cent of the people in this country "mistrust" Muslims, and not only that: 42 per cent agreed with the phrase "If there is discrimination against Muslims, it's mainly their fault."

In other words, more than half of Canadians don't trust a group of people because of their religious affiliation. And a lot of Canadians believe this is the Muslims' own fault.

To my mind, the 52 per cent number is definitely too low, though it should be too high. Allow me to explain:

Like the great song from the musical Avenue Q says, "everyone's a little bit racist." We all carry biases and petty vendettas against various races, ethnicities, cultures, sexualities -- it's an emotional response that, for whatever reason, is hardwired into our brains.

You can't get away from it, not all the time at least. The racist thoughts creep back in when things don't go the way you want them to. It's such a simple solution to life's ills that it can be hard to reject out of hand.

I'd bet a good two-thirds of Canadians, probably more, are actually mildly racist toward Muslims, not because they specifically hate Muslims but because they are, in one way or another, mild racists at heart. That inherent racism is only expressing itself now as mistrust in Muslims because, lately, some very angry and militant Muslims, in the name of Allah or Osama bin Laden, have been responsible, more than any other group of people, for making Western living a little less light-hearted, a little more stressful than it was before Islamist terrorism became a fact of life.

But that sort of faint racist thought in and of itself isn't really a problem and can't really be classified as such if more than half of us are doing it. No, the real problem is that 52 per cent of Canadians conceded their tame racism out loud. In that sense, the number is way, way too high, alarmingly high.

The flip-side of "everyone's a little bit racist" is "but no one should admit to it." There's a very valid reason for this: to verbalize one's odious biases is to make racist thoughts actionable. How so? Because when you say something out loud, there's a good chance someone else is going to hear it, and a decent chance he'll repeat it, and so on -- thinking a private thought doesn't hurt anyone, but stating or acknowledging it can. When you utter those words, they hover in the ether, there for the next person to discover and assimilate.

Which leads us to the other big number to come out of the Léger poll: 49 per cent -- the number of Canadians who say racism is most often spread via the Internet.

In a sense, this is unsurprising: mainstream T.V., radio, and print publications long ago banished any and all racist expression, but the Internet remains a relative Wild West -- all sorts of sick people that would never in a million years be invited onto a CNN set or the pages of the New York Times can broadcast their own slickly produced "news" online. The most banal of Google searches, worded slightly wrong, can lead you to a racist website, and often these pages appear wholly similar to your average news, networking, or information page. Racism, in other words, is living openly online.

The 49 per cent number is particularly scary, because it suggests that half of Canadians, by design or unwittingly, are encountering racism online. Despite laws on the books to combat it, racism still operates with impunity on the Internet. There's no excuse for this -- strictly enforced Internet hate laws are a no-brainer: as the Internet becomes the primary engine of our work and social lives, as it becomes our main means of communication, education, and entertainment, we should be making every effort to keep racists from spreading their hate there, and when they manage to slip through the i-cracks we should be prosecuting them. We wouldn't allow such hatred to find a home in/on classic media, why should we let it have a free pass online?

Getting serious about racism on the internet won't end the racism that exists in our brains, and it won't stop Canadians from mistrusting Muslims. (That will likely only happen when someone, or something, else takes radical Islam's place as the predominant threat to our way of life.) But at least doing so will keep the haters from spreading their bile. And then we can comfortably get back to our silent -- and perfectly benign -- personal racism.

 

Follow Yoni Goldstein on Twitter: www.twitter.com/yonigoldstein

 
 
  • Comments
  • 86
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
11:38 AM on 03/26/2012
Instead of hitting the racist button, you would do well to look at the fear factor.

After hearing many comments from my many contacts, I have come to the conclusion that Canadians are not expressing their racism, rather they are fearful for the future. A common comment is "as muslims numbers row inn a country, violence follows. The more muslims, the greater the violence".

jEarly on, the pressure is slight and veiled. For example, hahal meat in Quebec or, some years ago, sharia law in Ontario. This seems like a slippery slope culminating in coptic Christians being murdured in Egypt or nuns in Indonesia.

All in all, Canadians are fearful, very fearful.

Prove me wrong.
11:06 AM on 03/26/2012
I'm sure somebody said this already but Musilim's are not a race.
08:17 AM on 03/26/2012
The only thing I might, to some, sound like racist, is when there is a movement to change my Canidian Heritage, ie, turbans in the RCMP. That is not against all, just those who come here, then want to turn Canada into a little" peice of home " for themselves. Welcome, but like it for what it, as it is, for better or worse, or leave, it was your choice to come here.
08:09 AM on 03/26/2012
As a white male, living with a native gal, was married to a asian gal, I for one have seen both sides of racism. In some cases, a "minority" will cry racism simplely because he/she don't get their way. An I will say, that as a white male, I am sick an tired of being the bad guy! It' getting to the point where we are passed by, or over-looked simplely because a "minority" will cry foul if they don't get the job,or hand-out, or what ever. An yes, that has happened to me, I had better qualifications, but some one threatened the company with a discrimination claim.
02:04 AM on 03/26/2012
This is the link to the Leger Marketing Survey commissioned by the Association for Canadian Studies and the Canadian Race Relations Foundation:

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/yoni-goldstein/racism-muslims_b_1374398.html?ref=canada

What is most striking about the survey is the discrepancy between English Canadians and French Canadians in their degree of trust of Jews. 81 % of English Canadians trusted Jews, while only 44% of French Canadians felt this way.

Why?
09:11 AM on 03/26/2012
Correction. This is the link to the Leger survey: http://www.acs-aec.ca/pdf/polls/Racism%20and%20Prejudice%20Sources%20Trust%20and%20Blame.pdf

Put another way, 19% of English Canadians did not trust Jews, whereas a majority of 56% of French Canadians did not trust Jews.

But before the descendants of Isaac get all worked up, consider how the descendants of Ishmael fared among French Canadians: 57% of English Canadians trusted Muslims, while only 30% of French Canadians trusted Muslims. Or put another way, 43% of English Canadian did not trust Muslims, whereas a whopping 70% of French Canadians did not trust Muslims.

The descendants of Abraham should team-up and demand a Royal Commission on this. Or maybe, we should simply pull the plug on Radio-Canada.
photo
Add In Canadia
Egotism is a weakness
09:00 PM on 03/25/2012
I have an inherent distrust of religion, so I'd label myself as anti-religionist as opposed to being 'mildly' racist.

I have as much problem with Arabs as I do any other racial background: None.

Additionally I'm more afraid of Christian extremists more than I am of Muslim extremists.

So really I think the polled question was completely loaded and unfair, as is the assertion of this article.
01:10 PM on 03/25/2012
The main reason their is a negative view about muslims is very simple. Look at the state of the countries they control. Not a pretty sight.

Mass immigration is wrong for the West, specially when the cultural difference is so wide.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
logicanada
Blogger, radio co-host, writer, editor, voice-over
12:47 PM on 03/25/2012
Wrong. The majority of 1,522 persons surveyed are against Muslims. Don't publish articles based on surveys that must be sold to the public through the very article in which they appear. Some might call that propaganda.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
emphatico
....is politically radioactive.
11:52 AM on 03/25/2012
Islam and Christianity are equally bad.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:35 PM on 03/25/2012
You know a tree by its fruit, not by what the media says about it.
11:48 AM on 03/25/2012
This doesn't seem like a worthwhile article. If we try to ban or outlaw every little bias, every unguarded word, we'll create a world no one will want to live in. We're all biased to some degree in favour of our own group, simply because we know more about it and it's naturally top of our minds. Muslims, too, are biased on the same grounds against all non-Muslims ("They're not as moral as us. Look at how they dress. Look at what their daughters do."). Rather than trying to enforce thought and word control, let's just preach tolerance, respect and a willingness to get along pleasantly with others. Social norms are enough to keep most of us in line.
12:16 AM on 03/25/2012
Muslim isn't a race
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WoolyBumblebee
Creator of TruthAndOblivion.com
09:21 PM on 03/24/2012
Ah religion! The best way to promote hate and fear.

I wonder what the results would be if they asked questions about Atheists. We are the most distrusted group in the USA because we don't believe in silly fairytales. I wonder what Canadians think of us?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
colpy
01:28 AM on 03/25/2012
Naw, atheists are not mistrusted because they don't believe in fairy tales......

Atheists are mistrusted because they murdered at least 100 million people in the 20th century.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alex Betsos
04:24 AM on 03/25/2012
Well sir I'm assuming you're talking about the soviet union in this particular remark. But if we're going to look at the world this way, then we can look at all the people who have killed in the name of some "god" or another. I'm not going to mention any names but the National Socialist party of germany may have been Christian, as well as a Thomas More, a man responsible for killing other Christians for reading the bible in another language. Then we could talk about George Bush, he's a christian and he killed lots of people in Iraq in the same way that Stalin or Khrushchev. Or we could talk about the killings under the Borgia in the time of the Italian City States.

Now did all these people do these things BECAUSE they were Christian. Well besides Thomas More I would say to some degree yes, but for the most part no. Did Soviets kill people because of their religion? Yes. Were all 100 million because of that? No. Bad people do bad things. God or a lack thereof has very little in most cases to do with it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kenneth T Tellis
08:01 PM on 03/24/2012
Yoni Goldstein talks of the racism against Muslims by Canadians but it seems to me that he is suffereing very badly from selective amnesia, because their has been RACISM that is openly being practised against English-speaking and other Canadians by the Kebecois (Metis) people who run Kebec from June 22, 1974 after passage of RACIST BILL 22, by the Robert Bourassa government of Kebec, which caused 800,000 English-speaking and other minorities to leave Kebec. This was followed by the Fascist Parti Quebecois government of Rene Levesque that created a Language Police to prosecute people who violated their Draconian Language Laws which were voiding Constitutional guarantees.

Now where were you Yoni Goldstein when all this was happening? Perhaps it was too hot a potato to handle and so you just kept quiret hoping no one would be any the wiser for it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
see-ellen2001
09:49 AM on 03/25/2012
Hmm...seeing as that was over thirty years ago and looking at his photo I am guessing he was in school perhaps.
photo
albertarick
These are questions for wise men with skinny arms
11:16 AM on 03/25/2012
More like a sparkle in his Papa's eye.
01:05 PM on 03/25/2012
And I'm sure they was no reason whatsoever to pass those Draconian Language Laws because the french population of Canada had always been treated on a equal level with the english population. The french did that just out of spite because, you know, that's how the french are.

By the way, racism is about race, not language.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:29 PM on 03/24/2012
To associate Islam, which is a socio-economic religious system that dictates the way of life for billions of people from all races, is deeply racist. People live in free country where we are free to criticize, or even hate, Islam. If people cannot separate a legal right to hate Islam from an ideological campaign to associate critics of Islam with racism or bigotry then that is their problem. I can't stand Islam and I make no apologies for my ability to articulate Islam's inherent contradictions yet if I saw a Muslim in danger of drowning I would risk my own life to jump in to save them in the name of Jesus. ;) I don't assume anything about a person based on their race, because I am not racist. I can, however, safely assume many things about any average Muslim, Jew, or Hare Krishna for that matter because those things are written in books and ascribed to by devotees of those faiths. Honestly, the author must have done really well in a liberal-arts college, because only there can you get away with such a lack of critical thinking.
05:34 PM on 03/24/2012
Yoni, here's another headline that will give us a laugh at this year's Seder:

English Canadians Trust Jews (81%) More Than They Do Protestants (77%) and Catholics (74%)

Happy Passover everyone!