Huffpost Politics

Lac-Megantic Explosion: Thomas Mulcair's Criticism Of Tories Sparks Controversy

Posted: Updated:
NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair has been accused of sinking to a “new low” for slamming the Conservative government after the deadly weekend rail disaster in Lac-Megantic. (CP)
NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair has been accused of sinking to a “new low” for slamming the Conservative government after the deadly weekend rail disaster in Lac-Megantic. (CP)

NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair has been accused of sinking to a "new low" for slamming the Conservative government after the deadly weekend rail disaster in Lac-Megantic, Quebec.

Mulcair suggested to CTV News on Saturday that Tory policies directly contributed to a "tragic" explosion that killed at least five people, with 40 still missing in the small Quebec town.

"We are seeing more and more petroleum products being transported by rail, and there are attendant dangers involved in that," he said. "And at the same time, the Conservative government is cutting transport safety in Canada, cutting back the budgets in that area."

The NDP leader said it is clear Tories are cutting in the wrong areas.

"When we have a discussion about these things in the coming months or years let’s remember this day," he said. "We are watching a magnificent little village being burned to the ground by toxic products that were being transported through it."

Former interim Liberal leader Bob Rae was quick to voice his displeasure with Mulcair’s comments with a tweet that was promptly shared hundreds of times.

Andrew MacDougall, communications director for Prime Minister Stephen Harper, also took to Twitter to lambaste Mulcair for "putting politics ahead of the people."

Mulcair’s comments also sparked discussions on Twitter with some saying they crossed the line and others suggesting it was a totally appropriate criticism from the opposition leader.

You can see a sample of some reactions in the gallery below.

Close
Twitter On Mulcair's Lac-Megantic Comments
of
Share
Tweet
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide

Mulcair’s remarks represented a change from the conciliatory stance he took during his visits to Calgary last week. The NDP leader suggested at the time that Alberta flood victims need help, not partisan swipes, and called on all political leaders to pull together.

"I honestly do believe the federal government is doing everything it can," he said at a pancake breakfast on Thursday. "They’ll have our full support. There are times when we will talk partisan politics. This isn’t one of them."

So, the question remains: Was Mulcair’s criticism of the Harper government after the Lac-Megantic disaster appropriate in his function as the opposition leader or in poor taste?

Tell us in the comments below.

With files from The Canadian Press

Related on HuffPost:

Close
Lac-Megantic Explosions, Fire
of
Share
Tweet
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

Video: Public deserves answers over Quebec train derailment: Mulcair

NDP's Mulcair visits Lac-Megantic

Mulcair slams Harper over Lac-Megantic, blames rail cost-cutting

Quebec town looks like 'war zone' after train explosions: Harper

Latest derailment sparks questions about safety of rail system

Provincial aid sweeps into Lac-Mégantic

Fears toll could surge: 5 dead, 40 missing after Lac-Megantic rail disaster

Five confirmed dead, more than 40 missing after Quebec explosions

Devastated Lac-Megantic begins a work week, with its core shattered

About 40 people considered missing in Quebec train disaster; five declared dead

 
Register To Vote